@MaiqTheTrue's banner p

MaiqTheTrue

Renrijra Krin

1 follower   follows 0 users  
joined 2022 November 02 23:32:06 UTC

				

User ID: 1783

MaiqTheTrue

Renrijra Krin

1 follower   follows 0 users   joined 2022 November 02 23:32:06 UTC

					

No bio...


					

User ID: 1783

The way most people do it, sure. I don’t think it’s entirely useless, but most people do it in the form of collecting lots of “toys”, most of which are going to be useless in the exact context you’d want to have that for.

The gun for example, is extremely dependent on industrial production. You can burn through bullets with an AR in a matter of weeks. You cannot, however make more bullets or more gunpowder (Captain Kirk aside). So 6-8 weeks into a crisis, most guns will be useless. The same is true of generators. They run on gasoline. No gas, no electricity. Or maybe solar panels which you can’t make and if they break down you can’t get more. Can you really store not only gasoline and replacement parts to keep that thing running, and do you know how to fix them.

Even if you stockpile food, you can’t really stock up longer than maybe 3 months. Then what? You can’t just go back to your local grocery store and replace the stockpile.

In all of these things, it’s mostly about a transition if you really think that civilization is going to end, eventually you’ll have to take on the production of things yourself or create things to barter with. The world post apocalypse is going to look very much like the end of previous civilizations where people live in small communities doing most things themselves.

To me this makes learning skills probably just as important as anything else. Not like don’t stockpile, but if that’s all you’re doing, it’s going to fail long term. You have to learn those old skills and find a way around the industrial processes that you’ve been working with for most of your life.

I think they do have some effects, but it’s in combination with social isolation and lack of other activities. Isolated people are much more susceptible to media messages in general, and if you’re soaked in a message where killing humans solves problems, it’s going to put that in your head.

I am personally not big on therapy for anything mundane. They generally don’t help much better than simply bouncing ideas off any other person. In many cases they end up being worse simply because therapy is designed to treat serious mental health problems, and thus the things that might help a person with serious issues often hurt people without because they teach fragility and hyper sensitivity to feelings. This makes sense if you’re in such bad shape that your feelings make it impossible to live, but for most people it ends up hurting them more than helping. CBT is a small exception, though since it’s based on Stoicism, you could start with books on stoicism and see if they help.

My big thing is to prepare for the things you’d need no matter what actually happens. 95% the preps are actually the same. Nonpershible food, water, warmth and security without access to the grid. That’s the same whether it’s hurricanes or dirty bombs or war or famine. After you have that and enough to hold out for however long it takes, you can add on from their to protect against more specific threats.

I think Honestly, the best way to reclaim and recover organic culture is the twofold process: stop consoomming product (meaning unplugging from media slop), and to rebuild those lost traditional forms and stories and activities. If you want organic culture it has to come from a community that shares values and ideas. You get there from people sharing their lives.

I agree, but given that all of these catechisms and other written texts are easily accessible by modern people, I find this kind of thing to be troubling. It doesn’t bother me when you disagree on some dogma, but it’s simply bad faith to speak confidently about what a group believes without bothering to read what they say.

I think a lot of the perception of major differences is due to a lack of common vocabulary. If you understand salvation to mean “an afterlife with Jesus” then just about everyone would say “it’s the faith”. If you include things like being healed from sin or made holy, then you add in works to some degree.

This creates problems when motivated debaters tend to straw man what other Christians actually believe. Orthodox Christians especially converts tend to argue with the strawman version of Protestant belief of “faith alone” and implying if not stating that Protestants believe that Christians don’t live more holy lives but just have faith in Jesus like they have fire insurance. No Protestants actually believe this. Or it shows up when Protestants strawman Catholics and Orthodox as trying to earn salvation, which ignores that both groups absolutely say that faith is essential for salvation.

I think a lot of the difference is actually about the Protestant innovation of separating Justification from Sanctification. In most Protestant churches, soterology is about just going to heaven. Sanctification is a result of justification, and thus really not in the picture. I find orthodox and catholic theology to see the process of sanctification as a part of salvation and thus you end up with each group agreeing but having no idea they actually agree.

Power in our system is a two way street. It isn’t so for other systems. It’s both a blessing and a curse.

On one hand you get some say in what people do with power, on the other hand most people are ill suited to running a company let alone a society. And also getting a say means that you open the door to the government running your life. If we had a system where no voice existed for us plebs, I don’t think they’d be interested in using power against us. Propaganda in dictatorships is easily ignored and doesn’t affect much of the cultural life of the people. In democracy, every organ must be turned to the propaganda of the elite.

I agree that really the only benefit that any website like this is having a strong community of actual people who are interesting to talk to. This isn’t going to change by adding features. It comes from creating a community in which there are conversations with said actual people about interesting things in threads that are not just about politics.

Creating that is less about technology and more about getting people interested in talking about things. Creating a sports thread and a thread for books or gaming is as easy as creating a top level post. I think creating multiple federated subs would create less community because it puts people into one part of the website into that silo where they would never talk to the res5 of the users. Reddit was that. If you were in the food part of Reddit, you never talked to anyone outside of that.

Im not taking the oath on his hat…

I’m not sure, but I’m assuming the BoM doesn’t say to do that. I’d probably just affirm my oath or ask for a more appropriate book.

If the text contains the Bible you are still swearing on a Bible. Im not sure about the exact rules Jews have for such a thing, but I don’t see a problem with swearing to the god I believe in on a book that contains every word he wrote. I can ignore the additional material. If you told me to swear on a copy of the Book of Mormon, I wouldn’t do that because it doesn’t contain the word of god at all. So it would be a bit more like what is happening with the Muslims— the book, from their perspective contains nothing but man’s words and isn’t proper.

The Jew was swearing in on a book he believed in. Bibles, all bibles contain every book that Judaism considers scripture. The entire Tanak is in the bible. There are extra books, but, unlike Islam that doesn’t believe in any of the books of the bible, it’s not like it’s a completely different book.

My reason for saying that you need to start somewhere is that at some point, the thing needs to be actually done. The alternative is doing nothing at all. Which is where most of our problems have languished for decades. Putting up a tarp makes sense if there’s someone around who will actually fix the roof. If you are in a situation where it’s either you get out your hammer and nails and at least try, or you have a tarp over the hole for a decade, it might be worth the risk to at least try. I feel that way about most of our problems at this point. The problem has been there for decades, and nothing has happened. We’ve been “thinking about” getting manufacturing jobs back since the 1990s or earlier. We’re still thinking about maybe dealing with the absolute shitshow of college and the cost of college. We have been talking about illegal immigration for half a century. If we never do anything in hopes that someone will eventually get around to it, it won’t happen just like all these other things that the experts have done nothing about. At least this stands a chance of moving the incentive structure towards making things here.

I think there are people, a very small number, have conditions that require therapy, and an even smaller number benefit from drugs. The problem I have is that the methods and techniques of therapy can and often do cause normal people to develop mental illness for the same reason that giving everyone statins would be likely to cause all kinds of health problems. Treatments don’t work on people who are not sick, and messing with healthy bodies makes them sick.

I think overuse of therapy and the invasion of therapy and therapeutic methods into mainstream culture is causing a lot of harm. It seems to cause people to be narcissistic and neurotic and to become chronic over thinkers in ways that create problems both for the individual and society at large. It’s lead to people choosing to turn their feelings into facts and thus operate in a way that makes their actual real life worse than it would be. If you cut everyone off you get mad at, or set yourself tons of boundaries, you’ll end up miserable and alone. If you quit jobs because you don’t like doing some unfun things, you’ll never build a basis for a career. If you only exercise when you feel like it, you’ll never do it.

CBT and DBT are the only two therapies that I think work well.

I haven’t yet met a conservative who disagrees with deportations per se, most of the objections come from optics. The way it’s being handled might be discomforting to the boomer neocon right, but I’ve yet to hear them suggest that deportations should not happen. They thought illegals should be removed, but they prefer that it be done in ways that they don’t have to see it on their news feed. They wanted invisible deportation, which wouldn’t work.

I think it’s familiarity. In 2016, Trump making jokes was a novelty, nobody else in politics was doing what he was doing. He would post a funny or hyperbolic tweet and the media would lose their minds over it. It would be talked about everywhere, by everyone, and his opponents would go crazy and yell about what he said.

In 2026, it doesn’t work because everyone is used to this style of politics. He posts, and everyone is just thinking “he’s just trolling, it doesn’t matter, and not worthy of attention.” So he posts, and thud, nothing happens. So it doesn’t land, and doesn’t help the cause. It’s like going back and listening to an edgy comedian from the 1980s. It’s not that it wasn’t funny, at that time in that cultural context, but that in 2026, our culture and our taboos have shifted and what would have been outrageous in 1986 is tame now. In the late 1980s, there was a show called Murphy Brown, and it attracted attention from politicians because it portrayed a woman giving birth as a single mother. I don’t think anyone would care in 2026. We are used to it. We know how the joke ends, and it’s just not gonna attract attention in 2026.

Trump honestly hasn’t changed much since 2016. But because we are no longer shocked or even surprised by Trump being Trump, it doesn’t land. So what worked in 2016 is boring in 2026. We’ve seen it all before so the novelty of Trump doesn’t work for him anymore.

My contention is that you also have to start somewhere and such a major economic shift is not going to happen quickly. I think Trump’s method is off because it’s all stick and no carrots which isn’t good. If the tariffs were more targeted and there were major tax breaks for building manufacturing in America, it would work. But I see the necessity of doing something to create manufacturing in America, and unless we start somewhere we won’t ever have a manufacturing base.

It’s been going that way for a long time. De Touqueville was right in suggesting that once the idea that the government exists to give them personally things, it was all over. Unfortunately that’s the biggest problem with democracy, because the way to win is to promise to do exactly that. You promise to give people more gibs than the other guy, and win. And because democracy is about winning elections and not necessarily governing, you end up with people who know how to pander to their base, to promise various forms of gibs, to loot the treasury and pass legislation that would hand the prosperity of society to your base, and not to run the country in a sane way that promotes growth and security.

Im not saying that he’s doing so in the perfect way, but unless it actually costs more to import, there’s no incentive to build in America, and to hire Americans. It’s just basic business, unless it costs less to build and hire in America than to import, the business community will build in Pakistan, Sri Lanka, China, Mexico, or El Salvador. Your underwear comes from El Salvador because it’s much cheaper to build in El Salvador, hire Salvadorans, and ship to America than it is to build in America and hire Americans. Increasing the cost of imports is part of encouraging American manufacturing, probably would work if they had done other things to lower costs to build and hire in the USA — tax breaks or rebates, preferential treatment in getting government contracts, and so on. But it doesn’t change unless the cost of imports goes up enough to offset the cost of American manufacturing, it doesn’t happen.

Yes the regulatory system can add to the supply side costs, but it’s really not the only input, nor is it the biggest. The supply of chickens and the cost of labor and the cost of shipping are huge in determining the cost of the chicken at the store. Inspections and labor laws are part of that, sure, but if the chickens cost more, there aren’t a lot of levers to pull. They cannot unilaterally set the price of chickens. And I don’t think anyone here wants to live in a world where the government could unilaterally impose prices on anything because it would require the government to control most of the economy. It would burn the economy to the ground.

It’s not that there aren’t many conservatives, it’s the difference between defense and offense, offense only has to get past the defense one time to score. The defense has to stop the offense every single time or they lose. So if im watching a game and one team is trying to run out the clock on defense and the other is trying to score, I’ll always predict the team on offense to win because again, they only need to get past one time, the other team can shut them down for 99% of the game, but that one goal in tge last ten seconds means they lose.

I think the government has no real levers to pull on prices. The city doesn’t decide what rotisserie chickens cost, the grocery store does. And really, I don’t think most of the people in this country really get that. They expect that the government can lower prices or give them a better job, a fictional power that the government doesn’t have. And most people are really honestly too dumb to understand how things work in government, and are thus prey to near constant propaganda that tells them that the government exists as a personal butler to go and fix their job and the prices and make sure bad stuff doesn’t happen while also not doing anything mean to prevent that.

It’s stuff like this that convinced me that democracy is a terrible idea that mostly destroys everything in the name of government giving people what they say they want when the message is contradictory and incoherent nonsense. People want low taxes, tons of services, welfare, bullet trains, education for everyone that thusly guarantees their kids a high wage job. It’s not possible, and when the government ties itself in knots trying to do it, you get either gridlock or insanity. I’d much rather have a leader who knows how things work to put the state on the right track and keep it there. The public doesn’t know what it wants.

I don’t think JKR is hiding her power level. It’s much more likely she didn’t really think through her magical system and didn’t realize that she made the Pureblood faction right simply because of how her system works.

Way of Kings with the magic coming from Shards means that having such a powerful stone means you have magical powers. You thus have a system that is based on minerals. Something like Earthsea runs on the logic of knowing the “true name” of things, which would mean the logic leads people to horde knowledge. The way that magic works shapes how people perceive their world. She just sort of tied everything to bloodlines and then tried to ignore that if bloodlines determine magical abilities, people will be very concerned about bloodlines.

This is more an example of Sanderson’s Rule: even if you don’t show everything about your magic or technology systems, you better know what you can and can’t do and how it works.