vorpa-glavo
No bio...
User ID: 674
Caring about the personal ethics of people you see on TV is parasocial behavior. Jensen Huang cheats on wife, user 2rafa hardest hit?
I think this is a silly point to make. Jensen Huang is a part of our larger social fabric. His actions affect us, and though the effect is more diffuse, our actions can affect him.
I'm reminded of Plutarch's anecdote about Aristides the Just. The Athenians would hold a vote each year deciding which politician to ostracize, exiling them for 10 years, and one year an illiterate farmer unknowingly asked Aristides to carve "Aristides" onto a pottery shard so he could cast his vote to ostracize him. Aristides asked the farmer if he had ever been wronged by Aristides, and the farmer replied that he had never even met the guy, but he was tired of hearing him called "Aristides the Just" everywhere. Without revealing his identity or arguing, Aristides just carved his own name into the shard and handed it back to the farmer.
While the anecdote is mostly about Aristides living up to his epithet, I think it also shows a way in which parasocial behavior can cross over into action that affects real people. Even before TV or the internet, people's lives were affected by politicians and businessmen who they might never meet, and people felt the need to intervene through the ordinary political and social process to the extent that they could.
Why do you think you get a vote?
I mean, people voted with their dollars. The stock market gave people the ability to say how they felt about the situation and its effect on the company and its shareholders.
Yeah, I feel like this might be one of Scott's barber pole things.
How many polyamorous people are successful politicians or CEOs? In the realm of culture, how many blockbuster movies or bestselling books have polyamorous characters? Even in the realm of celebrities, there just are not that many polyamorous people.
From where I sit, polyamory is tolerated in the Silicon Valley set, and among the lower class dinergoths. With a well-known actor or musician the public might tolerate polyamory (the way Twisted Sister and David Bowie got away with gender fuckery in a pre-woke era), but I honestly think the idea that polyamory is everywhere or is accepted by general society feels extremely online and disconnected from reality.
If anything, adultery is much less common now than 40 or 50 years ago
I wonder how much of that is because of online porn and camgirling.
I was listening to Audible's podcast about Only Fans, and they mentioned that some survey had found that the majority of users of Only Fans were married men.
When your wife is getting treated for breast cancer, it is much easier to have a discrete "relationship" that lives entirely on your phone, than to actually go out and find someone to cheat with. (The example isn't random, one of the girls on the podcast mentioned being confronted by the wife with breast cancer over one of her regulars.)
I think you're in a very weird circle if you think that the latter is the prevailing attitude among the population at large. Polyamory is certainly tolerated in more Bohemian spaces, but it has basically no recognition or acceptance in normie spaces.
I also think it matters the context you're trying to shame someone in.
The idea of monogamy and cheating is still the prevailing norm in American society, which is why we shame people who cheat, and why people who cheat keep what they're doing secret. People who are engaging in polyamory with each other already know they're going against the grain of American society, but they do it out in the open, so they can't easily be shamed for what they are doing.
It's like trying to blackmail someone with a "secret" that literally everyone knows about them. It loses its punch.
It would be too expensive, for one.
Would it be too expensive in a world with cheaply made, abundant humanoid robots to replace laborers in agriculture, trucking, grocery stocking, etc.?
There will always be scarcity and opportunity cost of some kind, but I don't really see why basic subsistence for the masses would be out of reach for a future with more technologically achieved material abundance than we now have. If AI ever starts messing around in the world of atoms in a big way, UBI seems like a trivial option.
The bigger problem is there wouldn't be a lot of incentive to set society up to keep the human masses alive, if the humans don't provide any benefit to society over another robot, either physically or mentally. Like, even if the decisions are made by humans, if the humans are relying on the advice of AIs, there's probably a sense in which humans are really just rubber stamping decisions made by smarter, more powerful AIs, because those will tend to have the best outcome for a given human policy goal.
He had the affairs, but someone decided to release this information now, despite the Trump administration supposedly knowing about the Chinese spy for a while now. They even waited until just after the midterms to leak the information.
Congress did approve large settlements under Obama.
The cases where Congress didn't under Obama were usually because the government was suing a private company, and the settlement was being paid out by the company not the government.
When people say Trump is doing something 'unprecedented' I feel like 9/10 times it something that either Biden or Obama did or tried to do first.
I've been a little unpersuaded by this line of argument, since Trump's version often ends up being worse than the "precedence."
I don't like Obama's Dear Colleague letter, but Obama was trying to change policy on something non-central to a university's core function. Trump's Harvard letter was about 70% reasonable, and then the unreasonable 30% went so much further than Obama's that he managed to make Harvard look like the good guy in that whole affair, and Harvard had been flagrantly violating the law for years.
Obama's sue and settle stuff is similar. When Obama did big payments as part of it, he had Congress approve the spending. Trump set up a non-adversarial process involving himself, and then settled with the government to create a big fund to give money to whoever he wanted, and he didn't ask Congress to approve the settlement fund, which makes it much, much worse.
Like, you can't keep saying, "but I do have precedence" over and over again, while doing something 20% worse each and every time. Sure, there have been a lot of US presidents, and basically every one of them has done at least one thing that was legally questionable. You shouldn't speed run doing every single precedented rotten thing any president has ever done.
Preserving "our democracy" in plain opposition to a majority of voters.
I mean, at least some of the logic of constitutional republics as opposed to direct democracy is that some things are literally off limits to vote on. In theory, even if 90% of Californians were in favor of dispossessing every legal gun owner in the state, the Supreme Court would strike such a law down, and rightly so as a matter of law.
While trans rights are not enshrined in the Federal constitution, state courts can have different precedence around state constitutional provisions that might validly allow them to strike down a law like this under their state constitution. I don't think they should if they want to win going forward, because the same blue wave that gave the Democrats Texas also rejected trans rights even in already purple or blue states, and I think the Democrats have better odds in the next few years if they field "normal" candidates, who don't take the "wrong" side of an 80/20 issue. If they boil the frog like they did with gay rights, I think they'll have better odds on trans rights.
I don't think that's what Christians believe about oaths. Generally, I think they just think it shows a person is trustworthy and follows the same values as them.
There are even some Christian sects that take Matthew 5:35-37 as forbidding Christians from swearing oaths:
34 But I say to you, do not swear at all: neither by heaven, for it is Godβs throne; 35 nor by the earth, for it is His footstool; nor by Jerusalem, for it is the city of the great King. 36 Nor shall you swear by your head, because you cannot make one hair white or black. 37 But let your βYesβ be βYes,β and your βNo,β βNo.β For whatever is more than these is from the evil one.
Based on that, if oaths have power in Heaven, it is in strengthening Satan.
I have a hard time explaining why this line of reasoning just does not land at all with progressives. To me it seems like a slam dunk. What am I missing? And is there a conservative equivalent to this, i.e. a meta role reversal where conservatives are the one being hypocrites?
I mean, I think some of it is that there is some level of specificity when considering the symbolic meaning of something, such that "reversing the roles" doesn't always scan.
To use an example, when Keith Ellison became the first Muslim elected to congress in 2007, he was sworn in on Thomas Jefferson's Quran. I think in a year when 9/11 was still fresh in everyone's mind, and Muslims were our main boogeyman, the intention of that was to signal that even though he was Muslim, he considered himself American and wanted to tie himself to a founding figure of America to make that clear.
Despite this, conservatives like Denis Prager still managed to find something to complain about it in the affair, pointing out that before Keith Ellison, everyone from Jews to atheists were willing to swear their oath of office over a Bible, and so Keith Ellison should have been forced to do so as well.
Except, honestly, I think those Jews and atheists were kind of wrong to swear an oath on a book they didn't believe in. It's kind of weird that in considering the reversal, Denis Prager effectively says, "I would rather an elected official start their time in elected office as a liar and a hypocrite, as long as they swear allegiance on my tribe's book."
I am reminded of the case of Charles Bradlaugh in the UK, who was elected to the UK parliament, and spent six years repeatedly refusing to take a religious oath and was thus refused his seat, only to be re-elected in every by election that followed. Eventually, he took the religious oath, but in a way, taking the oath after six years of very clearly stating he did not believe a word of it, and subsequently being seated actually showed how meaningless the oath was. They didn't care if they were being knowingly and blatantly lied to, as long as the proper ceremony was being observed. An honest man, they refused to seat for six years. A liar and a hypocrite they happily seated, and in doing so undermined any credibility that the oath all of them had taken could be taken seriously.
I do not buy that she βwantsβ to wear a hijab. Where are all the American women who are raised without one, and then realize that they want to wear one, if wanting to wear one were an organic desire? No; she was raised to wear it by fear of hellfire or promise of heaven, with a side of social exclusion and social propaganda, which she still believes. Maybe this is good, or maybe this is bad, but itβs no different than how a Handmaid would be raised to don the Azorean hold, or how an Afghan girl would be led to wear a complete niqab. βWear this or Abdul will beat youβ is a a primitive understanding of the patriarchy in action.
At this level of analysis, I'm not sure that anyone "wants" to do anything that they were socialized into growing up.
Do Western women "want" to shave their legs, or did they watch their mom do it growing up, get taught how to do it as they were growing up, and get treated like gross social pariahs the one or two times they forgot to shave in the high school locker rooms, and got male attention when they shaved their legs and wore something that showed it off? It might not be hellfire, but men and women get socialized into the idea that hairy legs on women are somehow "unhygenic", when nobody thinks this about hairy male legs. Most people just uncritically adopt the standards of dress and grooming of their culture, and have very little interest in rocking the boat.
It is the difference between autonomy (self-rule) and heteronomy (rule by others). Diogenes might be the extreme end of autonomy, a person who so thoroughly questions society's rules and expectations that he lives out of an old wine tub, does strange philosophical stunts, masturbates in public, bites people, eats in the agora (the horror!), and he does it all while thinking that he's better than the fawning sycophants who abandon all dignity to beg for power and prestige from someone else, the sheeple who uncritically follow society's rules and norms, and even the rulers who cannot be happy with the palaces and lands that they already have.
Our age is arguably an age of heteronomy. There have always been people who uncritically follow the social norms of society, but the internet has enabled a world where new loyalty tests can be beamed out and adopted in an instant. You get the microtrends of fast fashion, where women buy cheap shit they'll only wear once because it looks cute and is trending. You get a euphemism treadmill that is faster than it ever was in the TV, radio or printing press eras, so fast that it starts to look like madness to people who don't keep up with it.
I have a buddy who works at a warehouse for a major grocery store chain in the United States. Relatively dumb people are still absolutely necessary for society to function. While they get to use tools like electric pallet jacks and scissor lifts, a lot of it is just guys on their feet wearing jackets and working in a giant room kept at the temperature of your refrigerator (or if they're really unlucky, your freezer) and unloading pallets from trucks as they come in, moving depallettized product around so that it can be put in long term storage, or loading it up into a truck and taken to a store.
I don't know if you'd consider it "hard labor", but the vast majority of Americans do not eat without those guys' work. Of course, I do expect the job to be automated away eventually (especially with the advances in robotics and AI we've seen), but for now all of those people's labor keeps most of the rest of us alive.
(I also don't know the specifics of the situation, but my understanding is that about half of the warehouse workers are only able to speak Spanish. I don't know if they're illegal immigrants, permanent legal residents, or citizens.)
Whatever his wife said, his own letters reveal he didn't care much about sex. I don't have strong feelings about it, but I could easily believe he was in the bottom 25% in terms of male libido. Capable of fulfilling his conjugal duties as a husband, but not super into it.
H.P. Lovecraft was probably more scared of women than he was of brown people and Shoggoths.
I don't know if it was that he was scared, or somewhere on the asexual spectrum.
It is pretty revealing that his most "interesting" female character was actually a body-swapped male sorcerer.
Topically for transgenderism, though, there's a particular 'you only think it's desexualized because what the sexualization actually is won't be coherent to you' thing that over time people (particularly men) might hopefully be starting to understand. Steven Universe does it with the 'fusion dance', but most people get frame-trapped by seeing the Fusion dances, going 'it's obviously sex, they're teaching kids to have sex', and ending the scan there.
While I mostly agree with the fact that there's a lot of transgender transformation media that manages to be sexual for a person with a particular kink or fetish without registering as sexual to most of the population, I also think there is a risk with this kind of speculation.
To use an ancient example by way of analogy, look at the animal transformations in Ovid's Metamorphoses. In particular I want to focus on the motif of voice throughout the poem (translation A. S. Kline):
But when he [Actaeon] sees his head and horns reflected for certain in the water, he tries to say "Oh, look at me!" but no voice follows. He groans: that is his voice, and tears run down his altered face. Only his mind remains unchanged. What can he do? Shall he return to his home and the royal palace, or lie hidden in the woods? Shame prevents the one, and fear the other.
Ovid focuses on the voice, and the lack of it in transformed people a lot throughout the poem. But why is he doing it?
I think there's a temptation for a modern person who is aware of the wide variety of kink content online, particularly transformation media, to speculate as to whether this isn't essentially ancient transformation porn. On this reading, Ovid keeps coming back to the lack of voice that results from a bestial transformation because this is the part that is hot to him, the part where a superior human being is made lesser, and thus, in a pattern that mirrors BDSM, hypnosis/mind control content, etc. the part where Ovid places himself in the mindset of a dom looking down on his literary subjects.
But there is obviously another explanation. That Ovid had a normal, non-kinky interest in transformation stories, and he chose to focus on the lack of voice in ex-human animals because that was one of the most salient differences between a human and an animal in his mind.
We will likely never know which of the two explanations is more directionally true.
But this kind of applies to all media that isn't obviously sexual, while appealing to a subset of the population due to their particular kinks. Plenty of mainstream stories feature body swaps (Freaky Friday being the most famous example), but body swaps are also a popular subject in kink. Short of an author or group of authors just coming out and saying, "This is a kink thing, we're writing kinky porn that only looks non-sexual because you're normal and this doesn't turn you on", there are going to be many examples where a cigar is just a cigar, and no intentional kinkiness was actually intended by the author.
It kind of works. The Death Eaters ally themselves with many of the outcasts of wizarding society like giants and werewolves.
Considering how scandalously Hagrid's half-giant ancestry is treated, and the way Umbridge talks down to the centaurs, and the things Dumbledore says about the lie of the Ministry of Magic statues (which depict all the other sapient magical races looking up to wizards), I think it would be possible to reframe Voldemort as a populist getting all of the hated rabble and dregs of society onside along with a handful of elites, and revolting with them.
I do wonder about the werewolves and giants that sided with the Death Eaters. Even if they enjoyed "being themselves" during the war, surely they understood that there was no way that a blood purist group would ever give them a good deal once the war was actually won. Like, the Malfoys might be willing to do an alliance of convenience with Fenrir Greyback, but it's kind of hard to imagine them ever accepting or tolerating his existence long term after a victory.
I'll admit, that I hope the full text of her actual statements to police get released, since right now we only have the DA's summaries and snippets from newspapers that have apparently obtained the full text. I'm particularly curious about the context of this quote:
βAnd then, of course, I was being hit at the same time. Physically hit very, very hard,β she told police, according to the transcript.
Considering that the DA determined that her statement didn't merit criminal charges initially, and he doesn't mention hitting at any point in his summary of her words, it makes me wonder if it was just rough sex / BDSM stuff, or if the DA has misrepresented her statement and things were more rough-and-tumble than the mostly consensual drug-fueled triple threesome narrative in his summary?
Cornell, in the spirit of an elite research university, has developed the inverse: rapists, but no rape.
This case feels quite opposite of most. Speaking as one of our resident perverts: I both find the actions of the men disgusting, and it sure feels like some of them were at best neutral on the question of consent; and I think the girl pretty much consented to what happened.
Yeah, it's a weird case. All of the guys were trying to get as far as they can with her and initiate making out and groping, but generally respected when she said no, backed away, or swatted their hands away.
If the DA's summary of her statement is accurate, then for the most part it seems like she verbally consented to a lot of it, and somatically consented to basically everything else. If anything, the part that comes off as most scummy is the final threesome. Males 3, 5 and 6 seem to have already been trying to wind things down, and then Males 1 and 4 usher her to a different room, convince her to do more ketamine and have the final threesome of the night before she taps out. It definitely reads like Male 1 caring more about his ego than her well-being, even if he was also high on ketamine and probably drunk as well.
I think there is a difference between not accepting someone else's beliefs, and and shitting all over them.
When you merely don't accept someone's beliefs, I think it is can be perfectly within the confines of good faith, to find points of agreement between their worldview and yours, and to argue that a person should live up to their principles and commitments.
The progressive left is slave morality, and Christianity is slave morality, so it is not surprising that even secular progressives find a lot to admire in Christian ethics, even if they also dislike a lot of aspects of conservative Christian dogma.
Yeah, to be clear, I was responding more to the meme itself than Scott's tweet. I don't actually think Scott's tweet is a good example of the meme.
Some have pointed out that this is Alexander doing the meme
While I haven't personally seen this meme, I do think there is actually a reasonable steelman for this type of argument.
To use one example, if I saw a self-professed Hindu killing and eating cows, and I was a secular vegetarian, I might reasonably ask the Hindu why they are being hypocritical when I thought their faith said doing that was forbidden. In this hypothetical, I obviously have ulterior motives as a secular vegetarian: I want less cows to be slaughtered for food. But pointing out your opponent's hypocrisy on a set of principles they claim to follow is a legitimate tactic in most cases, even if you don't accept their beliefs.
Now, because I am not a Hindu, I might actually get their faith wrong. It would be completely fair for the Hindu to respond that Hinduism is not a monolith, and prohibitions on cow-killing differ based on region and caste within India, and different sects within the faith treat it differently. If they said that in their native region of Kerala, within the caste they belong to, killing cows is acceptable, then my argument would have no bite at all. But if they really are being hypocritical with regards to a set of principles they claim to follow, then bringing up the argument can serve two possible purposes: 1) try to get them to actually follow their principles, or 2) within a discussion in a public place like Reddit, make it clear to other commenters that they are not following their own self-professed principles.
I think the biggest failure states in this kind of argument will just be the failure to fully understand a body of knowledge for an ideology or religion you don't belong to, and the fact that even when you do understand the ideology/religion and make a well-aimed argument at an opponent's hypocrisy, they can just bite the bullet and be hypocritical or cherry pick and ignore you.
But what does that prove today in the context of AI?
So really we should figure out the nature of the disagreement.
I'm willing to try to drill down to our different cruxes.
By this logic, most writing is mostly the product of computers and pens.
To be caused and to be made is the same thing. If I dig a hole with a digger rather than a shovel or my hands, nobody would say i just "caused" the hole.
I think there are lots of examples where humans set processes in motion, but don't necessarily own the final result.
If your campfire accidentally causes a forest fire, you didn't "make" a forest fire. You couldn't take a picture of the aftermath of the fire and say that it is a piece of art or artifice that you created, at least not with the same level of ownership that an oil painting has, even if the destruction has a certain aesthetic elegance or beauty to it.
And if you set up a bird feeder with a motion-activated camera, you might take a bunch of nice pictures that way, but I think despite you causing the photos to exist, you have far less ownership over the final photo than a photographer might have. If you disagree here, I would ask how you feel about frames from security cameras as a form of art?
When writing words down or typing them up, there is almost a 1-to-1 ratio of bits of information created by the human, and bit of information represented on the page or screen. That isn't the case with LLM-assisted writing. Generally, I would say that the tool is providing the vast majority of the information present on the screen, even if the human is essential for steering that towards a "good" output.
And I think that's completely insane and that the exact opposite is true, self evidently. So really we should figure out the nature of the disagreement.
What do you feel is the best, concise non-anthropomorphic explanation of the Huggingface incident, and how would you prevent such loss of control incidents in the future?
- Prev
- Next

The answer to your point is easy to make within the virtue ethics tradition.
A person's actions are downstream of their character. If a person has spent a lifetime building habits of personal moral excellence and turned themselves into a paragon of virtue, they won't succumb to temptation when presented with opportunities to cheat or engage in dirty dealing for personal gain.
In the Renaissance tradition that built on Aristotle's politics, there is an idea that the character of rulers and public figures is more important than the character of ordinary people, because the ruling class sets the tone for the rest of society. If the ruling class behaves as aristocrats in the original sense of the term, embodying the best traits of humanity, then the masses will benefit from it in countless ways. If the ruling class behaves as self-serving oligarchs only concerned with their own benefit, then the rest of society will suffer as a result.
On this view, it does matter if Jiro does any of the bad things you mentioned, but it matters far more what the moral character of Jensen Huang is like, and the three affairs gave us our answer.
More options
Context Copy link