This is just one of those 'roll up, roll up, come and see the freaks' articles. No different from girls committing suicide because Cumberbatch got married, or whatever. How people should interact with AI is something we're working out individual by individual - and I say that as someone whose job makes them very well aware that they're trained programs - but this stuff is a sideshow.
And GTA VI may deserve that praise, for all I know. When you said
take on its own terms for what it is trying to be
it resonated with more general thoughts I've had about how increasingly consistency with an artistic vision is elevated above fundamental crowd-pleasing in literature, fim, TV and games, and why that might be. I've tried to convey some of those thoughts above; I'm still working on them.
I don't think it's so simple. The market has expanded massively since the time of GTA, and competence + reputation + marketing budget will get Rockstar a relatively stable slice of that big pie no matter what. There is also a heavy cofounder in that hype and reviews tend to be more driven by the previous entry in a series rather than the current one. Bioware was a giant until it just died.
I think demand for a long-running series is like other forms of retention: it holds steady and then suddenly collapses, as new alternatives become available and everyone realises that everybody else isn't interested either.
Certainly GTA VI is competent and will have an audience no matter what. It's in a much better place than much of Western media. I do think that place is declining, and it's declining because too many people ask 'did it achieve what it set out to achieve?' instead of 'was it good?'.
What I'm trying to convey is that the end goal of all this development is making something so awesome and fun that loads of people will give you loads of money so they can do it. Preferably they love it so much they fling money at you in preparation for next time too.
"Making a Gran Turismo game" or "making a Hitman game" or "leaning into the crime drama aspects" are all meta goals that inform how you approach the base goal of making a fun product. The genres of 'Gran Turismo' and 'Hitman' originally came into being, in a fairly organic way, in order to achieve this base goal.
The danger is that these meta goals become Goodharting. These meta goals are much more legible than "is the game really really really fun". Questions like "did Rockstar successfully transfer Bonnie & Clyde to the modern day" or "did they keep the trademark GTA anarchic spirit" or "have we finally achieved the ultimate sandbox" are fun and interesting questions to debate on blog sites and in dev meetings. Leadership can set the goal of "recreate GTA 3's anarchic spirit" and check in after each sprint and broadly tick it off. Deciding whether a game has achieved what it set out to do is fairly easy, and if the team is as competent as Rockstar, the answer will almost certainly be 'yes'.
The more fundamental question of "should they have set out to do this", i.e. "is this the best, most fun, most awesome thing millions of people can do with their Friday night" is much harder and more contentious, and has been increasingly avoided by Western cultural output since the 90s.
A counter-example is Halo CE. The dev videos are very open about their philosophy of '30 seconds of fun'. That is, the next 30 seconds should be really fun. Then the 30 seconds after that should be fun too, in a slightly different way. Then the next 30 seconds. The gameplay, the enemies, the vehicles are ruthlessly honed so that the next 30 seconds are going to be really, really good seconds and everything else then follows pretty organically.
Meanwhile, 343 Studios went in very explicitly wanting to 'make a Halo game' and 'pay tribute to the lore' and they worried about retention and social-media cut-through and all sorts of other stuff, and the very simple 'is it awesome? is it really fun?' goals fell by the wayside.
Nonetheless, take on its own terms for what it is trying to be, it's quite remarkable.
I think this is my issue with a lot of Western output. What matters for me as a customer is what I want it to be.
Anybody can be consistent. It takes a genius to be entertaining.
But then you have to follow that argument on and establish that 'good judgement' in the sight of @HereAndGone2 makes for more valuable and effective leaders than the way Huang did it.
Honestly don't get the insistence on committing what would be absurd amounts of developer resources on all the minigames and chores.
Easier to justify I think. Spending millions on fairly mediocre gunplay if youre unlucky or really pretty good gunplay if you're lucky doesn't elevate you above baseline expectations or produce breathless articles. It's hard to market 'fun and feels good'.
Maybe Bond has more cultural cache among men in Britain than I thought?
I would say so. Doesnt everyone want to play Bond? He got to do Batman already, and did it well IMO.
Wise advice. I suspect unchallenged authority over something means a lot to people, and makes them much more reasonable than they might otherwise be.
Ohhh, sorry. I meant $0 as in "I already pay $100 for GPT, so using it for my tax/legals as well costs $0 on the margin". Not literally free.
I'm English, taxes work differently here. I have used Fable for genuine legal issues. I spent £3000 on my solicitor, and about £200 on Fable.
Fable went through all my documents, found all the traps, gave me advice and wording that generally worked out well and solved my problem.
The solicitor rang me up, gabbled some.advice down the phone that basically boiled down to "don't trust these guys" and then went on holiday for two weeks. He did help but his help was almost entirely in reviewing stuff and giving a thumbs up to the final contract.
If I'd only had the solicitor things would have gone far worse for me. If I'd only had Fable things would have been basically fine.
The question is when and if paying $0 for my monthly GPT subscription and tanking the very rare fines becomes a better deal than paying $5000 a year.
The requirement to take legal responsibility for their advice also makes lawyers surprisingly unhelpful in my experience. They become gnomic and unhelpful, requiring you to work out the correct advice from their extremely limited (and therefore completely defensible) hints.
It's registered to an American company run by an (ethnically) American researcher setting up an AI-powered dating agency.
I'm not sure what you mean by 'sophisticated' and 'effective' here? The complexity of financial products? The convenience of websites?
A bit, but I'm sure Elon genuinely respects him. Software is full of such situations where people are of equal capability but different ranks, because seniority has as much to do with timing and founding status as skill. Usually those relationships work out fine. Sometimes they can even be a nice break.
No idea. I'm not OP, just an annoying guy with a theory about why 27% of sales being non-financed is reasonable.
I'm just saying, you took the maximally negative interpretation of those results and the maximally positive looks very different.
More importantly, you are trying to build a picture of the 'average incel' by consulting a survey whose gloss begins:
This community operates almost exclusively online, often serving as an outlet for misogynistic hostility. Concerns about violence from incels have positioned them as a growing (inter)national security threat. This study, the largest primary investigation of incel harmful attitudes and beliefs to date
and then taking the worst possible combination of responses as representative of the average person who persistently can't get a girlfriend in 2026 (which is how the common parlance uses the term). I'm sure you're posting in good faith but I think your sampling and interpretive strategy is very bad.
Ignoring the fact that this is obviously a very extreme selection, combination effects mean that potentially as few as 3% of surveyed incels were "an autist who lived with his parents and contemplated killing himself every single day".
(0.5 * 0.3 * 0.2=0.03)
Then you get into the fact that these people in 1986 wouldn't be living with their parents (the proportion has massively gone up recently), would have had more opportunities to meet people in IRL and improve their social skills, etc.
Yes.
Isnt this basically selling A for cash, buying B using that cash? If youre moving from owned house to owned house, or downsizing, theres no reason to take on debt.
Okay, that's fair. They executed well, though, and my point is more that NVIDIA (and Huang) weren't just silly gamers who got the AI revolution magically dumped into their laps.
The Rosenbergs exported the power to obliterate millions of innocent people in an instant. Huang exporting the power to break up America's attempted stranglehold on globally-relevant technology seems to me to be quite another matter. Especially since they're his own damn products.
Imagine you never saw dice before, but God made some and told you to roll them. You roll them. Then they disappear, and nobody has any interest in making dice again. Does it make sense to talk about the probability distribution of the dice roll? I think it does.
I don't personally believe that thought experiment is applicable, or a wise way to think about one-off massively-multicausal events in the world as it actually is. You do, I get that, but I don't.
It could say he got lucky a few times.
I think this is hubristic. Strive to attribute to luck what was luck, sure, but assume merit before you assume luck. If you assume merit, the worst that can happen is you will overindex. If you assume luck, there is a very real danger you won't learn anything at all, to protect your ego.
Right, but you should counteract survivorship bias by looking at all the people who also did that and did not get super lucky.
What would I learn from that, beyond to temper my expectations and not to take super risky moves? Which I already know.
The fact of the matter is that some people succeed and some fail, and the ones who succeed are usually more interesting and more qualified along multiple axes than the ones who fail, and provide more to learn from.
Thank you, I know what probability is. Talking about probability for one-off events where a true probability can never be established is intellectually and philosophically dubious, in my personal opinion.
Forecasting is one thing, you have no choice, but when we're talking about the past and other people's actions and the consequences thereof, I think it behooves one to show humility and study what successful people did rather than assigning their success too confidently to 'luck'. I think it produces a more accurate analysis.
Your analysis will be confounded if you can't separate the luck from the decision. A lot of people have this issue actually and it leads to cargo culting.
Certainly this can happen. To my mind, the point is to look at what they did in advance, and how much that put them in position to get whatever lucky break they ended up getting. I have no idea about Musk specifically but he's done well a few times now and that says something. Reading hagiographies uncritically can be fun too, of course, but that's more like a vicarious fantasy.
To quote Napoleon: "I like my generals lucky."
- Prev
- Next

No, that's not what I mean. It's important to separate stuff that is immoral from stuff that is ineffective. People love to lie to themselves and assure themselves that adulterers, nepotists, or callous employers are useless failures in addition to being immoral, but that's a delusion.
My point is that you haven't established that "do not give your useless incompetent kids fake titles at your company in order to pay them fat salaries for not doing any work" practically leads to "this is bad business and bad for the company". It's important to at least know which it is.
The woke play the same game in reverse. They think that pandering to criminals and minorities is morally righteous and therefore jump through hoops to convince themselves it produces mostly good effects for businesses and society. Thus convinced, they do far more damage than if they realised that what they want doesn't work very well, decided to do it anyway, and put measures in place to alleviate the worst effects. Being clear-eyed is important.
That's wrong. It doesn't matter if it damages the company or not. But one shouldn't twist an argument about moral justice into an argument about material effects, however rhetorically effective it is. Hume famously said you can't turn an Is into an Ought, but going the other way is even worse.
More options
Context Copy link