@roystgnr's banner p

roystgnr


				

				

				
1 follower   follows 0 users  
joined 2022 September 06 02:00:55 UTC

				

User ID: 787

roystgnr


				
				
				

				
1 follower   follows 0 users   joined 2022 September 06 02:00:55 UTC

					

No bio...


					

User ID: 787

Throwing out things as nonsense is certainly more optimal way than considering all options, even clearly insane ones - but if done prematurely, it cuts off too much.

I think what's most counterintuitive is that the definition of "prematurely" grows widely if you've actually got a chance of pushing through some important limitation for the first time, because the most important competitions (economic, but also intellectual, etc.) are efficient enough that the only way to thoroughly win them is to do something that at first seems insanely unlikely to win. We laugh at "you can't win the lottery if you don't play!" suckers spending $2 for a ticket with an EV of $0.80, but how many of us are laughing because our expected utility calculations are correct, not just laughing because we've internalized "don't try something if the odds of succeeding are too low"? Smart venture capitalists will fund 20 startups knowing 90% of them will fail, quadruple their money with 40x returns from the 2 winners, and laugh all the way to the bank. I thought catching a giant rocket in more-giant robot arms was Musk's idea of a joke when I first heard about it, and then the guy who first put landing legs on an orbital launch vehicle was also the first to make them obsolete. As long as you don't fail in utterly ruinous ways, the cost of trying something insane and failing and having to try something else until you find the insane thing that works can be higher than the opportunity cost of avoiding failure.

From a quick glance at the major ones: ARM and Apple are doing fine (and in a much more diversified way), though they've been missing a lot of the GPGPU opportunities Nvidia seized; AMD is way behind Nvidia, but only because that's a high bar to clear, and they (surprisingly to me) haven't been falling further behind; Intel utterly blew it.

Not sure what it says that the second-best-GPGPU-tech CEO behind Jensen is Jensen's first cousin.

more time on woo-woo insane nonsense than he did inventing modern math and physics

To be fair to Newton, it's only after the time is spent and the results have been invented and studied that we can clearly see them as "modern math and physics". It's not necessarily obvious in advance that combining "stare at how the dots in the sky move" (mostly the domain of astrology) with "As Above, So Below" (from one of the Hermetic alchemy texts Newton translated) gets you to Universal Gravitation plus Newtonian Physics. Newton and his peers had already started turning alchemy into chemistry and astrology into astronomy and physics; it's only in hindsight that it seems obvious that theurgy was a total dead end. Even Newton's most important math was kind of wild, arriving at the fundamental results of calculus but with somewhat hand-wavy techniques that weren't reformulated with modern rigor until a century after his death!

The explanation that a lot of high IQ people, for a variety of reasons, accept creation as a baseline truth and work from there seems sufficient to me.

Yup. Intelligence is good at finding rational derivations of actual answers, but unfortunately if you're mistakenly confident that you've already found an actual answer then intelligence is also good at finding rationalizations of those instead.

Good thing you said "favorite" or I'd be tempted to dump 40 or 50. Here's a top 10:

  • I educate/teach, you influence/inform, he indoctrinates/brainwashes.
  • I give disproof/correction, you offer refutation/criticism, he has an attack/"gotcha".
  • My argument is inductive, yours is extrapolation, his is a slippery slope.
  • I am passionate, you are emotional, he is hysterical.
  • I uphold standards, you enforce rules, he gatekeeps.
  • My positions evolve, yours change, his flip-flop.
  • I call out hurtful speech, you moderate language, he polices tone.
  • I have a religion, you have a sect, he has a cult.

Genesis 1:3 is a great metaphor for the Big Bang! You can even include all of Genesis 1:1-4, if you allow for the same kind of creative license that modern science uses when we call a ball of incandescent proton/electron plasma "hydrogen" ("water-creator"). It's only afterward that it really goes off the rails.

It's that their good arguments don't agree with each other.

My favorite TalkOrigins page was always this one, specifically the table of hominid skulls where, "although creationists are adamant that none of these are transitional and all are either apes or humans, they are not able to agree on which are which".

I can't steelman Creation Science's results, but I could probably steelman Creation Science's study: it's generally valuable to have people who are looking for flaws in any current scientific consensus, because there are usually bound to be some, and even an irrational or hopeless motivation for seeking flaws is still a way to avoid the sort of comfortable conformity bias that delays or downplays finding flaws.

If you're inclined to become smarter and know more about the world, a single player game's storyline can help you

Certainly true.

just as well

And now I have to disagree, in two contradictory directions at once:

On the one hand, a single player game's storyline can be a work of art, not "just as well" as a book, but much better, in ways no non-interactive art form can match. The suspense of wondering what an author's internally-conflicted character will choose just can't measure up to the internal conflict of being forced to decide what you would choose in their place.

On the other hand, it probably won't. Making a story interactive in ways that are meaningful (e.g. doing side quest A before B or vice-versa doesn't count) requires the plot to branch, and every bit of writing that has to handle N branches makes writers do N times as much work as the audience gets to see, and the RoI for doing that plummets fast. Naively, n choices in a game gives you at least N=2ⁿ branches, so writers either have to make n small (my favorite huge choice is in Deus Ex, but there's just the one and it's right at the end), make the branches "decouple" (e.g. there's a half dozen other major choices in Deus Ex, but IIRC no writing that has to handle the cases for more than one of them at a time), make the branches "merge" (e.g. in Life is Strange episode 2 there's a bunch of choices with a single binary outcome based on "did the good choices outweigh the bad ones"), etc. Telltale Games was probably the best at making this kind of thing tractable, and they still get shit on for the compromises (Google "telltale games choices matter" - I get 2 neutral/nuanced and 5 negative opinions in the top results). The alternative is what you see more often: games where the writers don't risk disappointing you by even trying to make your choices significant. At best they give you sets of quests which each have a couple outcomes that only matter in short-term or materialistic senses, and at worst they railroad you, and either way you get a story that you could have read in 5 hours, diluted by 20 or 30 hours of gameplay.

Picked up There Is No Antimemetics Division next. I believe I've seen it recommended here before.

IMHO it's best to think of "it" as "them", a collection of short stories that connect into a series. I wouldn't say any of the stories is bad, but they vary from "fantastic" down to "good enough", with better setup than conclusion overall. It's easier to appreciate the conclusion if you go into it looking for "good enough" and being satisfied rather than looking for more "fantastic" and being disappointed.

You could also quit halfway through, so you get all the best stories and then move on, but (unless you have some other reason; e.g. my kids aren't big horror fans) that'd be kind of extreme. This is Antimemetic Division, not Battlestar Galactica.

all they managed to do was say - haha nerds are too unattractive for anyone to ever have sex with them voluntarily and without nefarious agenda.

The impersonations were funny too at points.

The funniest moment https://youtu.be/R_8UPhJNrZ4?t=187

Yeah, but mostly as meta-humor. They forgot we're supposed to be enlightened fourth-wave feminists now! Beautiful women aren't statistically less interested in electric cars, reusable rockets, virtual reality, AI, or software in general, they're just underrepresented in such fields because of ... what was it again ... oh, yes: techbro discrimination! That's right, the problem was all just techbro gatekeeping, which probably happens everywhere, assuming the entire premise of this skit is wrong and nerdy men definitely aren't drawn to beautiful nerdy women like moths to a flame.

Somehow SNL regressed all the way back to stage one on a culture war issue that moved to stage three around the turn of the century. No problem, though; the celebration parallax probably means they'll never be seriously called out for it. You can say "women aren't interested in nerd stuff", you just have to add "and it's good" when you do.

most people probably can understand the concept of a computer that makes itself smarter. It's really not a very complicated idea.

It's weird that it doesn't really figure into popular ideas of AI, though, isn't it?

In elite non-fiction we get "Speculations Concerning the First Ultraintelligent Machine" in 1965.

In popular fiction, just looking at your linked comment: you're right that "AI might be dangerous" is well-attested in popular fiction, but "AI might upgrade its intellectual capabilities extremely rapidly" not so much. WOPR/Joshua and HAL are dangerous mostly because of how smart they aren't, and Skynet and AM gain self-awareness but don't obviously get much smarter. There's a TNG episode where Barclay both gets much smarter and integrates with the computer, but it's all external influence, no runaway positive-feedback loop involved. Data is a little more realistic than C3-PO (the droid who's basically sapient but who isn't even obsolete decades later, much less creating his own successors), but it's still not surprising when Lal doesn't work and his research stops there.

The earliest popular fiction I know of featuring recursive self-improvement is A Fire Upon the Deep, so of course I went to the TVTropes page to see what the trope name was and if the trope page listed anything earlier ... and the only trope I see for the Blight is "Eldritch Abomination", nothing more specific. Even in that case, the self-improvement is essentially a "reboot" of previously-existing capabilities; in a sense the main interaction of the story with the idea of recursive self-improvement is that the "zones of thought" are a necessary gimmick to create a plausible future setting where superintelligence is a big deal but RSI isn't.

"AI capability is a function of accumulated research, and if that function's growth rate isn't slow enough then after AI can do any AI research y'=f(y) blows up" ... simple enough to squeeze into two clauses (for anyone who's had Calc 1; for "most people" maybe add a second or third sentence too), sure. But if you then add "we don't have reason to believe its growth rate will be slow before it hits far-superhuman levels" and "artificial-intelligence research is probably easier to do right than artificial-ethics research" then this has obvious implications of the Skynet variety, yet it's surprisingly hard to find people who were taking this seriously who didn't get there via Bostrom and Yudkowsky.

Binance. For billions of dollars' worth.

Stalin had prison camps devoted to R&D. I guess getting out of backbreaking labor and getting some vitamin C in your food is nice? Plus engineering skill made you less likely to be executed. But even Korolev (eventual top engineer of the Soviet space program, and already a leader of Soviet rocketry) lost a couple of post-Great-Purge years (and most of his teeth, to scurvy) in the regular gulag before he got an upgrade to one of the "good" camps.

We wouldn't be eager, but our grandparents would have been, and there may be less-whimpering generations in our future too.

Trouble is, atomic rockets kinda suck for (lower stages of) launch vehicles too. Specific impulse is great, but thrust-to-weight gets too low, unless you use something crazy like Project Orion. Maybe I'm being too pessimistic, and there's probably some nuclear-ramjet HTOL lower stage design that works around the problem in part of the difficulty range, but I'd bet there's a much wider range above that where even atomic civilization hits a pretty hefty wall before it can launch a satellite.

There is no way for me to indicate to twitter that the dumb, sprawling joke I just spent 3 minutes watching didn't go anywhere and wasn't funny.

In the "..." menu at the top-right of a tweet there's a "Not interested in this post" entry that works pretty well for me.

Numerically last night looks like it was smaller? I was going to point out the (roughly; only ~95% of votes in plus it depends on which election you choose as a baseline) D+20 shift in the Texas Senate race, but now that I look up details it looks like Scott Brown was R+43 vs Kennedy's previous election? Wow. I can't even parse that. Was Massachusetts full of Republicans who just really hated Mary Jo?

I don't think Musk cares about getting to consume more than a tiny fraction of his wealth, but he does care about getting to invest as much of it as possible in building things. SpaceX is very vulnerable to interference of the "oh, you wanted to make even louder noise near a sea lion? we'll be ready to review your environmental impact study in a year or two" variety, and even Tesla can get shut out of Let's Boost EVs From Everyone Except The Guy Making Them All central planning for reasons as hard to avoid as "noticing what unions did to Detroit".

He obviously sucks at politics, but it's hard to fault him for trying after 2021. I love all the photos of Biden literally crossing a (Jeep) Rubicon at that summit. No screenwriter would dare be so on-the-nose.

to say nothing of "Prediction Markets"

The nicest thing about prediction markets isn't that they always give the right answer, it's that they're increasingly-often an opportunity for anyone who's sufficiently more right. If there's no market, saying "it would take a miracle" is free advice to give but might not be worth more than free to you or your audience. If the market is 70/30, saying "it would take a miracle" means you're either about to make a lot of money, give a lot of money to someone who knew better, or find yourself pushed toward some valuable introspection.

But "muh Nate Silver!" will ever be the rallying cry.

Silver's final odds were 80/20. Seems a little low in hindsight, but he beat the spread.

We should probably replace the "national emergency" part of the War Powers Act with a new modernized set of rules, which I propose we name the "Everybody Has Fucking Cell Phones Now Act". Might the dastardly Elbonians hit us with a sneak attack? Sure! Does that mean we had best be prepared to let a President launch acts of war, for months on end, before getting Congressional approval like those dumbass Founding Fathers thought was necessary? No!

Perhaps we were all spooked during that brief window of history in which ICBMs were fast but communications were slow, but at this point incoming ICBMs are just about the only thing that we might want to make an exception for. For anything less, the Commander-in-Chief can spare 10 minutes to mass-message Congress and tally a vote before starting a war, because, as my proposed Act expressly notes: everybody has fucking cell phones now.

and within approximately five seconds

Looks like from the original viral drawing until the first viral use of "foid" was actually more than half a day? I would not have guessed that, but I'm not finding any similarly popular use of "Malfoid" any earlier, and it doesn't become a hashtag until 5 days later.

The best defense I've heard of the culture-warring here is the idea that "foid" acted as a shibboleth, preemptive offensiveness to keep away the "We have to do this My Way, because Your Way is Too Offensive" crowd and enable more creativity ... but I'm not sure the timeline works for that theory.

His church is extremely liberal (in both "open minded" and "leftist" senses). The top three images on their website are a video that begins by pointing at their "Love They Neighbor - No Exceptions" banner, a photo of a cross covered in progress-pride-flag-design drapery, and a "No Human Is Illegal" sign.

Whenever I visited (before my father's death but after he moved to Austin he was a member for a few years) everyone I talked to (including the current pastor making headlines, but I don't recall meeting Talarico) seemed animated by genuine faith, even if the level of liberal (in both "open minded" and "ample" senses) interpretation required for that faith gave it a very struggling/double-think tone to me. That sounds patronizing, but it isn't intended to. I met a lot of loving and helpful people there toward the end of that "before my father's death" period, and I'm a bit worried about the Eye Of Sauron now shining on the place. I did sadly conclude that their beliefs are wrong in a descriptive way, but there seem to be a lot of people now angrily concluding that their beliefs are wrong in a normative way, and I'm hoping that doesn't include anyone too unstable.

'Likes Paxton' is more of an ask than 'likes Trump' in Texas.

Looks like you're almost certainly right; thanks for the correction! Trump has higher approval and a higher (though still currently negative) net approval-minus-disapproval than Paxton in Texas. Trump has a higher percentage disapproval, but that's due to Paxton's larger "neither/don't know" numbers; if we exclude those from the denominator than Paxton's negatives are higher too. My only caveats are that Texas-only polls are relatively small and high-margin-of-error and that the polls I could easily find were slightly apples-to-oranges (job approval vs favorability, and I'm sure we could all name politicians who were good at their job despite being bad people or vice-versa).

Contemporary muggles were even winning at impractical "whoa this is cool" stuff in a few cases. From a Doylist perspective, noticing that would have led to a very very different sort of book series, of course.

Harry ... turned the pages of the book until he found the picture he wanted to show to Draco.

The one with the white, dry, cratered land, and the suited people, and the blue-white globe hanging over it all.

That picture.

The picture, if only one picture in all the world were to survive.

"That," Harry said, his voice trembling because he couldn't quite keep the pride out, "is what the Earth looks like from the Moon."

But from a Watsonian perspective it's kinda weird that we never saw one muggleborn in canon geeky enough to bring up any Muggle Pride factoids in the face of Slytherin insults.

Trump's approval rating is deep underwater in Texas. Paxton still has a good shot to win, because "likes Trump" is more of an ask than "likes Paxton" which is much more of an ask than "doesn't dislike Paxton enough to vote for Talarico instead", but the late polls are nearly all going for Talarico and he's favored nearly 3-1 on the prediction markets.

Bias warning: I've already cast my vote, for Talarico. First time I've voted (D) for a national-level race since 2008. (Half of the time the polls in Texas aren't even close and there's a decent Libertarian I'm free to vote for, the other half of the time the Democrat just sucks)

Edit: scratching out a claim that @hydroacetylene corrected me on.

Hah, I did type "Ringworld", huh? I'll edit that. My oldest daughter liked the first two Ringworld books but I warned her that they go downhill fast from there.

I'm ashamed to admit that, when I heard of the "Discworld" books after having already heard of Alderson disk worlds (probably from Niven, the author of Ringworld, partially explaining my mental short-circuit above), I thought the whole "you know, like flat Earth, but for comedy" thing sounded like enormously disappointing worldbuilding by comparison. It was probably 15 years later before I realized how wrong I was.

he has no reading stamina

I stand by my previous recommendations, but after some thought ... it might be worthwhile to focus on stamina-building reading before worrying about quality reading. If my kids hadn't gotten into the habit of devouring guilty-pleasures series when they were younger, they probably wouldn't have been up for more thoughtful things to read when they were 10. "Can read at a high level" and "can read without noticing any effort" are two different virtues, and there are all sorts of voluminous book series designed to make sure kids develop the latter. My oldest daughter's favorite was probably "Warrior Cats". I think mine was "Choose-Your-Own-Adventure" back in the day. Don't even sneer at comics! "Calvin and Hobbes" has something to think about at every level. "FoxTrot" was my kids' gateway to Star Trek TNG. Even "Garfield" (okay, you can sneer at this one, but sneer respectfully when around the kid) isn't worthless if it gives the kid motivation to binge read something for hours on end.