We don't have Jewish commentaries on Genesis from anywhere close, chronologically, to when Genesis was written and/or compiled so we don't actually know for sure one way or the other how people interpreted it "back then." The Genesis text was originally written (at a minimum) hundreds years before Philo. Thus, the surviving texts from Philo's era are in conversation with Greek ideas, rather than in conversation with the Babylonians and surrounding Canaanites, as Genesis is.
My understanding is that ANE scholars tend to think the entire question of "is this supposed to be literal or metaphor" is a misunderstood imposition on the creation texts of the time, which were serving in a liturgical role with an orthopraxic function. They come to this conclusion in part by cross-referencing other surviving works of the same time and era. For instance, in Hammurabi's introduction to his famous code, he says that he was called by the gods to establish justice. Now, again, we may not know for sure how people at the time understood this, but it seems quite probable that nobody at the time understood that to be saying "I, Hammurabi, literally talked to a deity" but rather that Hammurabi is invoking the divine cosmic order of the time and his position in it as justification for his laws. This does not mean the text is metaphorical - you'd really get in trouble for stealing, people at the time likely did believe in the gods and the cosmic system referenced in the text, and the actual conquests mentioned in the text are real.
And it's not even difficult to get this from a gloss of Hammurabi's code as translated into English, even without familiarity with the background knowledge, but for some reason when it comes to Genesis people sometimes pretend it's impossible in principle for the text to switch between genres in a similar fashion, and to have been understood to have been doing so at the time by its intended audience.
One thing we can be pretty certain of is that Genesis was positing a different cosmology (one that elevated man relative to other creation myths at the time, in which man was created to be the slaves of the gods), that it is full of send-ups or criticisms of other religions at the time, and that it and the rest of the Pentateuch successfully preserved Jewish culture in a way that dramatically outperformed their competition.
This is well within living memory: Frier gives a 15 year old a 34% chance of living to 55 and a 26% chance of living to 60, so if Mark is writing in 70 AD we'd expect plenty of surviving witnesses from an incident in 30 AD.
Also, the Gospel's don't spring up in a vacuum. It looks like some scholars believe there was a Q-text, or portions thereof, as early as the 30s, although late-daters will put it closer to Mark in the timeline. Even if you don't believe in a Q-text, or late-date it, Paul is writing around 50 CE (so a majority of 20 year olds would have survived the intervening 20 years) and Paul references oral traditions that are older than his letters and likely date to the 30s or 40s.
The Gospels could have been written in 34 AD and that wouldn't by itself rule out lying. But they also could have been written in 234 AD and that by itself wouldn't change the fact of relatively early attestation.
This isn't really what you find in the text if you look at what is believed to be the oldest portions of the Old Testament text (very unambiguously pre-Christian).
For instance, the Song of Moses is believed to be early, and it uses the term šēḏ (~demon) to refer to other deities and says that God allocated the portions of the other gods (look at the earliest texts on Deuteronomy 32:8 from the Septuagint or Dead Sea Scrolls) - in other words, it assigned preeminence to the Hebrew God. You see something similar in the Song of the Sea ("Who among the gods is like you, Lord?")
It is true the Elohim is a plural construction for spiritual entities, but it does not seem to only refer to deities as we think of them; see 1 Samuel 28 where Saul consults with a medium who says "I saw gods [Elohim] ascending out of the earth...An old man cometh up; and he is covered with a mantle" (this is identified by Saul as Samuel).
(As an aside, this entire scene is fantastic, very primordial-horror feel, of the sort of feel Eggers would put into a movie, or something.)
Protestants, by dint of their theological commitments, can't appeal to some spiritual authority other than the Bible. There's no clergy to dictate the correct interpretation. Everything comes down to the judgment of the individual in interpreting scripture.
This isn't actually how Protestants view things! Confessional Protestantism has creeds (including some they share with Catholics), catechism, and confessions they wrote at church councils. Even nondenominational churches will have statements of faith you have to sign to be a member, and those will be appealed to if you teach something you derived from Scripture that is contrary to them. Members of all of these groups will also appeal to traditional church teaching. It is true that other spiritual authorities are not considered infallible in Protestantism in the same way the Bible is, but that doesn't mean they do not exist.
The idea of the role of the judgment of the individual in interpreting Scripture isn't that all interpretations are equally valid, it is that individual members are supposed to do the personal work to come to correct conclusions about Scripture (and perhaps more importantly, let Scripture and the Holy Spirit shape their own mind through personal study.)
Quick example on this - the New Testament isn't really clear on whether credobaptism is the normative form of baptism or not. Thus, among Protestants, there is a lively debate over which direction Scripture goes, but any time that debate starts up in earnest each side is going to go back to church tradition (typically as early as possible) to bolster their arguments, referencing things like the Didache, early church fathers, and archeological inscriptions to make their case.
This isn't actually that dissimilar from the Catholic line - the Catholic line that binding councils cannot contradict Scripture. Protestants would say "our binding councils do not contradict Scripture" and then argue over whether or not that is true (Catholics will instead argue about what the council means.)
Does that make sense?
Saying the Bible is the literal and inerrant word of God introduces its own host of problems, but it forecloses a bunch of ideas that theologically conservative Protestants would prefer not to entertain.
Right, I think this is correct.
If Genesis 1, e.g., is a metaphor, that allows the possibility that other Biblical narratives are also metaphorical. You can argue this or that particular passage is/isn't a metaphor, but in the absence of some authority like the Pope it's just your interpretation against mine.
This I think is not the best way to look at this. Some interpretations are actually better than others - this is as true for Shakespeare as it is for Scripture. And I think all else being equal Christians today are better equipped to interpret Scripture than they were in, say, 1820. Thus it is far from clear (contra what YECers like to say) that the options are only "7-day creation or anything can be a metaphor!" You can say "the understanding of the text in its original context is the best interpretive guide besides Scripture itself for understanding the text" and then you can argue "in the original context of the Genesis creation arc nobody would take it literally any more than Christ's audience would have understood His parables to be literal" and in parallel argue "in the original context of the teachings of Christ, people would have understood His teaching on [e.g.] divorce as a morally binding statement." Now, this sort of argument might be wrong but an argument like this is not inherently narratively brittle, it is internally consistent. Does that make sense?
Maybe a better way of phrasing what I am trying to get at is that I don't think there is a widely held view that Song of Songs is only a metaphor.
Ah, yes, this makes sense. I do think Christians (and feel free to point out if I do this!) sometimes say "only a metaphor" when what they really mean is "not moral instruction" - so for instance ahhh recreating Song of Songs isn't something people are being instructed to do literally. (Similarly, Ezekiel cooking over cow dung is not a sign we must do the same.) This could lead to people saying "it's a metaphor" but I think you're not wrong to say "well it's love poetry."
Great effort was put into massacring adjacent heresies, Catharism proceeded along similar lines and was put down hard. Only later on was there a shift towards everything indefensible being a metaphor. It wasn't known in advance what was supposed to be metaphor and what was supposed to be fact, until the real facts were established.
Very much not true; the debate over whether or not Genesis was entirely literal likely predates Christianity (Philo being an early Jewish writer who discusses whether all aspects of Genesis were literal) and early Christian apologists debated this question roughly a millennia before the Cathars were "put down hard." This debate really is one of those "the more things change, the more they stay the same" things.
Genesis 1 and 2 even preserve two differing accounts.
That's likely not what's going on, actually – or, at a minimum, probably not all that is going on. (It's a little surprising to me the source you cite seems completely unaware of both the context in other Mesopotamian stories and scholarship surrounding them but also in the neighboring chapters of the book...) The doubled accounts is a common theme in ANE literature (for instance, we see a seeming "double creation" of man account in the Atraḫasīs). Moreover, in Genesis 1 - 2 specifically, the "doubled account" of the creation of man mirrors the seemingly "double" chronology in Genesis 1 - 11. In Genesis 4 and 5, and again in Genesis 10 and 11, we are presented with double genealogies, wherein the first genealogy introduces a big picture idea and the second genealogy; the genealogy of the first man in Genesis 1 and 2 has the same movement, from an unnamed man to a named Adam. (See Richard Hess, "Genesis 1 - 2 in its Literary Context"). You also see this structure in the Atraḫasīs, I think, with Mami making man with blood mixed with clay in the first account and the second account detailing that she made 14 people from 14 different pieces of clay and designing the human race to be male and female.
Obviously you can't rule out multiple sources being drawn from with this sort of analysis, but it does show that the choices were serving a unified literary purpose rather than cobbling together disparate texts semi-coherently. And the fact that you see this in other ANE literature (I'm having trouble grokking Enki and Ninmah but I think there's a similar pattern there too, starting with the wide-shot creation of man and then the detailed subsequent creation, during a drunken bet, of a number of infirm men) suggests to me a genre-pattern.
As a personal note, I've been reading Homer lately and you see a lot of repetition in Homer, although it takes a different form: Homer, famously, reuses epithets for characters, in part because it's a mnemonic aid.
Thanks for this, by the way, fun rabbit hole to go down! It made me reconsider some of my personal speculation about Genesis 1 - 2 (I had some interest in actually reading it as two distinct creation narratives arranged in sequence, but I think the parallelism in the rest of early Genesis makes it clearer they are the same event, being recapitulated.) I may need to pick up Alter's The Art of Biblical Narrative...
And the dates for the Gospels are in fact postulated to be very late (40 years at minimum, it's an ethernity)
The early critical scholars put them 100 years out or more, out of living memory of the depicted events! Which ties up my point nicely – my point is not that modern scholarship is saying "Christianity is true, you should believe it" but rather that it's very, very different from what was going on in the 1800s and early 1900s when the lore behind the current splits in modern American Protestantism was being written.
Even given the right circumstances I don't see the constellation of minor denominations finding another anchor point besides inerrancy.
Reformed denominations tend to believe in inerrancy but have never (in my experience) been particularly sold on YEC compared to [more] evangelical Christians, so if you don't see it, I would gently suggest that it's for want of looking :)
Glad that was helpful! I find this interesting to discuss.
The New Testament talks about the idea that the law of God is written on people's hearts absent even Scripture or the Holy Spirit.
I think this sort of bears out what we see throughout most of history. Even very cruel cultures often have at least some sense of moral reciprocity. But even the best cultures have a permission structure that allows one to harm others guilt-free.
And I would not say that is necessarily bad - or perhaps I would say that it is exactly that. It's probably good that we have a permission structure that allows us to defend ourselves. But historically a permission structure is what, it seems to me, permits abuse. People don't often say "theft is okay," "murder is fine," "rape is normal," they say "well Jews/blacks/Russians/etc. don't count." Fundamentally, what it boils down to, is often "s/he'd do the same to me." Which is why "bless your enemies" ended up being such a revolutionary moral idea.
Circling back to the (heh) genesis of this conversation, I think that "evolution" can (and historically has) become part of an abusive permission structure, thus the vehemence with which it is opposed (not only by YEC Christians, I seem to recall an article during peak woke about opposition from seculars for essentially the same reasons.)
I suspect it also doesn't help that a lot of confessional Protestantism is grounded in catechisms that were very literally written before modern Catholicism. Luther's small catechism was written before the Counter-Reformation was finished cooking; the Westminster Confession of Faith predates Vatican I, let along Vatican II. The Catholic church's stances today on things like "should we sell indulgences yes or no?" or "religious freedom, yes or no?" have changed dramatically since they were written. But the self-conception of both Protestants and Catholics sort of blinds them to seeing that in some ways Protestant churches are more (if I can use the phrase without seeing pejorative) stuck in their traditions than the Catholics.
A Modest Proposal is overdue for the Hollywood sequel treatment!
The second point is that, irrespective of what people think now, most believing Christians and Jews throughout history believed Genesis was literally true. So there are only three possibilities:
I'm not really sure this is true.
First off, I think we can agree that people can believe incorrect things about the text without the text actually being confusing at all. For instance, it's possible that most believing Christians think the "fruit" in the garden was an apple. Does that reflect poorly on the text? No - the text simply does not say this. We can extend this idea: if a popular version of the text is translated poorly, or ambiguously, and this causes a misconception, does that reflect poorly on the text? No, that can't be right. But (obviously) a lot of translation is itself guided by context. So if the text can be poorly translated for a lack of contextual understanding by the translator without it falling on the fault of the original text, it follows that the text is not at fault for being poorly understood for a lack of contextual understanding.
So Option 4. - the Bible (like any other text) is capable of being misunderstood through no fault of its own - has to be a live option, I think. Getting to another conclusion requires specific work (and there's an interesting discussion to be had if we should assume #2 is correct based on e.g. Matthew 13:10 - 12 etc. but set that aside for a moment).
You could try to salvage your trilemma by arguing that we shouldn't rely on what most people thought, but rather what literate, educated elites (who were more likely to properly understand what the text meant, due to better education, broader experience with literature, being able to read the text in its original language, etc.) Basically, if the people who have no excuse not to misunderstand a text all agree that it should be interpreted one way, it's easier to argue that it's the text's fault if it says something that seems untrue. This is also convenient, since we mostly don't know what most people thought, and have to rely on what educated elites wrote.
With that in mind, is it true that most believing Jews/Jewish educated elites throughout history believed Genesis was literally true? (By "literally true" I mean "7-day young earth creationist or something very similar" - you're welcome to tell me you have a different definition.)
From what I can tell, probably not. If you Google the first Jew to treat Genesis metaphorically, it will give you Philo. But Philo was active before even the Mishnah was compiled, and there's not a lot of commentary on the Torah that predates him, as far as I know. We do know that Philo *wrote against allegory-maxxers" because in his day they were using "it's an allegory bro" to disobey the law:
"For although the seventh day is a lesson to teach us the power which exists in the uncreated God, and also that the creature is entitled to rest from his labours, it does not follow that on that account we may abrogate the laws which are established respecting it, so as to light a fire, or till land, or carry burdens, or bring accusations, or conduct suits at law, or demand a restoration of a deposit, or exact the repayment of a debt, or do any other of the things which are usually permitted at times which are not days of festival." (See On the Migration of Abraham, 91)
So, as far as I can tell on an admittedly cursory investigation into this phenomenon, you're looking at a very spotty historical record and going "all of those people believed X." We don't know what those people believed! Most of what they wrote didn't survive! We do know that Jewish views on Genesis as allegory go back around 2,000 years or so and were widespread enough around that time that it caused social problems (at least in Alexandria).
Furthermore, yo must recall that most people who have lived have lived recently. Google tells me that most Jews who have ever lived lived in the past 300 years; it also tells me that even the very early Jewish commentary we do have was not inclined to interpret, e.g., the 7 days of creation as literal days. So I actually do not see a strong reason to think that most Jews or educated Jews throughout history have believed in what you might call a literal, 7-day-creation interpretation of Genesis. Even if you're wanting to grade on a sort of "most Jews per capita throughout history" basis I'm not sure it helps you much, given the antiquity of Jewish thought on the matter.
I think we could repeat this exercise with Christianity - even very early Christian apologists (Clement, Origin) also did not believe in a literal, 7-day-creation interpretation of Genesis. And most Christians today don't view Genesis as literal (at least in the United States), and, due to the explosion of Christianity, most Christians alive have lived in the past 100 years. (100 years ago, many conservative Christians did not believe in a literal, 7-day creation either - "old earth creationism" was very common). So I do not see a strong reason to think that most Christians or educated Christians throughout history have believed in what you might call a literal, 7-day-creation interpretation of Genesis.
This is all on a pretty cursory bit of research, so I am all ears if you have pushback. But I think it demonstrates the danger of assuming the past [40 years] is representative. Even if I am wrong about most of the above, I'm very much not wrong about that!
I tend to think alien life is far-fetched but this stuff makes for great literature. If you're a science fiction fan and haven't read High Crusade, stop what you are doing right now and get your hands on a copy.
(Admittedly High Crusade is mostly fun for reasons other than theological speculation...)
Evolution essentially implies the opposite.
A little bit more than that, even, evolution says man got to where we are by checks notes killing off the (hominid) competition, improving ourselves in the process.
Now, the vast majority of people like humans, but also wish they were slightly better, and, you know, people look to history to find innovative solutions to their problems...
The Christian cosmology is given in Genesis and takes the form of an Ancient Near East creation myth, not a historical account written with the purpose of giving the curious a scientific understanding of the origins of the universe.
Right, whatever else we know about Genesis, we can be ~completely certain that it was not written solely to appease the scientific curiosity of 21st century Americans. And with modern scholarship we do know that it was written as an Ancient Near East creation myth in form (which wasn't as well understood or appreciated 100 years ago). This obviously doesn't, as a textual matter, settle the question of, e.g., a literal 7-day creation - but I do think that asking the question "how would the ancient Jews have understood this" is a much better starting point than "how would I prefer to understand this"?
It also happens to be better for other areas literary interpretation, which is nice!
Then you only have the bible and it kinda has to be read literally, so as to make your correctness obvious.
You're couching this in sort of absolute terms, as if there's a sort of inexorable logic to the thing, but I actually tend to think these interpretations are more of an accident of history than it seems at first sight. (It seems I am making this argument today!) It's quite possible for conservative evangelical Protestants who takes the Bible very seriously and very literally to be skeptical that a literal interpretation of the Genesis creation story is the best one. Dr. Michael Heiser is my personal go-to example here, but I am sure there are others.
I am a little under-equipped to make a good case for the historical accident thing, but my argument would basically be that
- Darwinism and critical readings of Scripture arose about the same time and were both used to attack traditional Christian views of the Bible, ethics, and moral teaching. (It's worth noting that the higher critics were doing their work before Origin of the Species was published, so as far as I can tell there's no necessary link between the two.)
- Alternative, non-literal readings of the Genesis creation story, grounded in historical understanding of the text and the Ancient Near East, were underdeveloped at the time due to less knowedge (textually and archeologically), less scholarly attention, worse lingustic skills etc.
- Lacking 2 (and of course that any sort of scholarly criticism positing that Genesis was an ANE "creation myth" likely pattern-matched onto 1), conservative Protestants in the United States embraced a "literal" reading of the Bible (not particularly grounded in, say, how ancient Jews would have understood the text) to resist these trends.
Since conservative Protestant's are largely very interested in what the ancient Jews thought (recall that Protestantism is fairly invested in the entire idea of "getting back to the original church" and has some non-trivial claims to making steps in that direction), and given that scholarship has largely shifted to grounds favorable to Christianity (modern scholars are not, by and large, questioning if Jesus or Paul ever really existed, asserting that Pilate wasn't real, postulating late dates for the Gospels, etc.) I think conservative Protestantism is actually primed to move away from YEC literalism as regards the creation story, or at least be less dogmatic about it. If, in some counterfactual history, good, moderate scholarship, solid archeology, and knowledge of ancient texts had arrived before the (misguided) critical scholarship, I think it's quite possible that Protestants would have a much more Catholic-like approach to the entire thing.
Do you honestly think Iran’s leadership would be dumb enough to bomb Washington DC?
You can read what I think right here! TLDR; Iran is not a monolithic faction and some factions might benefit from this action, but perhaps more appealing to you, I think it is good for Iran's leadership to have the capability to bomb Washington, D.C., and one way to suggest that capability without using it might be to talk about it very loudly so that Washington, D.C. will hear of it. Wouldn't you agree?
I’m not a conspiracy theorist I just think Trump is that stupid and so are his advisers.
What would you prefer to refer to this...conjecture about a plan between members of a group to deceive the public for political gain...as?
I wouldn’t be surprised if this is something that came from Israel as a source.
CNN indicates that U.S. SIGINT (which is very good) picked this up directly. Certainly I wouldn't be shocked to learn that they obscured the originating point of the intelligence, nor would I be shocked to learn that it is Israeli, but I don't see any reason to rule out the possibility that the United States is capable of making these sorts of intercepts.
Yes, I caveated that statement specifically with the Evangelical Protestants point, which I thought was important because Skibboleth had mentioned they were disproportionately likely to adhere to YEC, and I wanted to raise a point where they were happy to accept metaphor (and Catholics are not) but maybe I didn't make that clear enough?
I think there's a big difference between "every word of the Bible is literally true" and "unless something it clearly metaphorical it shouldn't be interpreted as such"! I'd be much less inclined to quibble about the latter.
Jesus speaking metaphorically in the gospels about communion is not the same thing as saying "this narrative of events in the Bible is a metaphor."
I agree! But you said "the Bible...speaking metaphorically...blows open the whole endeavor..." so I was responding to that. Perhaps I read you too literally ;)
Nor, as far as I know, do literalists think that the apostle John literally became Mary's son.
Right.
Song of Songs is not metaphorical. It is a collection of romantic poetry that contains descriptive metaphors.
as far as I know the prevailing view amongst literalists is that while it has higher spiritual significance, it is also what it appears to be
Right, I think the dominant Christian interpretation is that not only does it contain metaphors, it is a metaphor for Christ and His church.
does not strip Christ of dignity
Hmm. I'm not sure that it didn't - particularly the part where Christ was crucified in a way specifically intended to rob a human of their dignity:
Let this mind be in you, which was also in Christ Jesus: Who, being in the form of God, thought it not robbery to be equal with God: But made himself of no reputation, and took upon him the form of a servant, and was made in the likeness of men: And being found in fashion as a man, he humbled himself, and became obedient unto death, even the death of the cross. (Philippians 2:5 - 8)
But I am happy to elaborate. Note that I said evolution can do this, not that it does - what I mean is more that it can be used as a tool, or part of a narrative package, to do this. Evolution (in the sense of how species change over time because of genetics by means of selection pressure) as a fact is morally neutral - as facts tend to be. But viewing it as an instrument it is very dangerous morally; I believe that treating humans like livestock, breeding and culling them selectively to achieve desired outcomes, is wrong, and hope you do too. Evolution also (as exemplified by this very forum) calls into question the practical equality of the races, in the sense that it suggests this process in the past may have equipped some races better for some tasks than others. Thus, by itself it's an "infohazard" in the sense that it is information people can do hazardous things with.
What restrains people from doing hazardous things with this knowledge is (partially) the sense that it's morally wrong, and/or a countervailing metanarrative. But the specific materialistic metanarrative that uses purely naturalistic processes - in particular evolution - as the explanation for the existence of all life on earth provides (by itself) no moral guideposts that says "we shouldn't do bad things with this knowledge" and greases the slippery slope by positing that humans are, like other animals, entirely the product of natural processes.
Christianity, following the path of Judaism, insists on inherent dignity to all humans as made in God's image regardless of their personal capabilities. (Interestingly it also indicates that animals and their well-being are worthy of moral consideration, but that's a tangent!) Replacing this with a purely materialistic metanarrative couched in evolutionary terms provides the means to treat humans like livestock, or call into question racial tolerance, but also at the same time removes any countervailing religious motive not to do these things.
Please note: I'm not claiming something like "people who aren't religious want to genocide other people" or anything like that. I'm just saying that materialism by itself can't do the work of Christianity (or any other religion that emphasizes human dignity) in providing a metanarrative that protects humans from the implications of evolution.
Hopefully that makes sense!
What’s this kinetic superiority I’m presently not seeing according to you?
The U.S. and Israel have been able to strike deep within Iran, is your position that they couldn't effectively strike the 500-mile logistics tail necessary to invade Israel, or that Iran can succeed at destroying a state through conventional bombing despite ~every other attempt at doing this failing completely?
It isn’t some kind of historical tragedy that’s going to replayed with different results.
Right, because Iran isn't going to "shift to total economic mobilization and launch a ground invasion on Israel." If they did attempt this, history would replay as farce.
"Every single Word in Scripture is literally true" is a strawman caricature that ~nobody in real life holds. For instance, I've never met anyone who thinks that Song of Solomon 4:12 -14 is speaking entirely literally and with no metaphorical imagery at all about a very secure garden with a pomegranate-and-spice orchard.
One also wonders why you think that Biblical literalists of all people would believe Scripture would always be straightforward and could never be a source of confusion given the literal interpretation of passages such as 1 Corinthians 1:22 - 24 ("we preach Christ crucified, to the Jews a stumbling block and to the Greeks foolishness"), or, say, Mark 13:14 ("let the reader understand" is clearly saying "I'm not spelling it out for you").
The ways Christians actually work to interpret Scripture and the debates about how best to do that can actually be pretty interesting and I can point you to some examples if you like. I'm sure there are others on here who could do an even better job.
To concede that creationism is wrong is to concede that the Bible is either wrong (and thus not inerrant, which blows open the whole endeavor) or speaking metaphorically (which also blows open the whole endeavor).
This isn't true at all - pretty much everyone agrees that the Bible speaks metaphorically (might I point you to Song of Songs? Or Christ's statement regarding His body and blood, which most Protestants - particularly Evangelical Protestants who are likely to be YECers - agree is metaphorical?) It's just a question of when it is best interpreted that way.
Hydro is correct that it's viewed as a trojan horse.
Do you seriously think if Iran was out to destroy Israel it wouldn’t impose total economic mobilization on the entire country and shift to 100% war time production of the economy?
I do not think that Iran would win this war if they tried to do this. The plan you are outlining is "mobilize hundreds of thousands of conscripts, throw together a logistical tail that previously did not exist, and drive more than 500 miles through neutral countries to attack an enemy with a considerable technological edge, essentially uncontested air superiority, and nuclear weapons."
What happens if you try this is that Israel bombs your supply lines with JDAMs and your hundreds of thousands of conscripts desert in the middle of Iraq. If you don't find that compelling, can I remind you that Iran has actually already tried this exact strategy against Iraq, except at a time when they had the technological edge, and the result was that they stalled out and had to make peace?
- Prev
- Next

Interestingly you get numbers in the Gospel, including for events a lot larger than "50." As we will see, there are extra-Biblical reasons to think that accounts of Christ's miracles were widespread, or at least not fringe.
We do have non-Christian sources about it! I think the reason we don't have more is that the First Jewish War resulted in Rome scouring Palestine, destroying Jerusalem, and generally overturning Jewish society, with the typical negative consequences for any local records that might otherwise have survived, including Roman and Temple records in Jerusalem. (Another possible reason could in theory be that people who saw Christ's miracles and wrote about them afterwards were disproportionately likely to be Christians although there are some counterexamples.)
So, if we're looking at sources outside of the New Testament for the "local view" of the time, our best surviving sources are, from what I understand, Josephus and the Talmudic references to Christ. And both sources reference the idea that Christ was a miracle-worker, so it seems reasonable to assume that there was a preexisting narrative along these lines. (There is some dispute over the accuracy of Josephus' account - although new work suggests that due to a missing word or two the text we have is best taken as much less laudatory of Christ than it has been understood to be in the past - but even reconstructions of the text minus the parts believed by some to be Christian insertions reference some idea of miraculous works - or, in the case of the Aramaic text, the resurrection.) Note that I am not claiming that Josephus was a Christian, just that Josephus is about as good a text as we have, and he seems familiar with the idea that Christ worked miracles.
The Talmudic treatment of Christ is very interesting, since from what I understand it is broadly in line with what the New Testament records: the Jewish religious elites do not deny that Christ is a miracle worker, but rather deny that the miracles come from God. It is possible that the Talmudic writers were not drawing on 1st century Jewish traditions of the Christ but rather responding to the Gospel narrative itself (in other words, instead of preserving an independent oral tradition, making up a new one to rebut the Christian narrative) but if that is the case, it seems curious that they frame Christ as real and possessing power rather than simply denying that He ever existed.
Not sure what you are referencing here, since my understanding is that historians agree this depiction references a real event, and there are in fact extra-Biblical reasons, leaning on rabbinic traditions of the time, to believe the temple practices Christ condemns were new, instituted around 30 AD (which explains the event). The debate is over whether or not Christ performed it twice, or whether John placed his account of the cleansing of the temple towards the beginning of Christ's ministry for thematic reasons (not necessarily an unusual technique by the standards of the time.)
Even if you don't buy the cleansing of the temple (for whatever reason) the fact that rabbinic sources point to a controversial change to allow a market in the temple around 30 AD and the fact that Gospel writers record Christ doing something about it suggests that the Gospel authors had good working knowledge of what was happening in Jerusalem at the time.
Paul explicitly claims to have met Jesus. This is why he switched teams!
More options
Context Copy link