@Shrike's banner p

Shrike


				

				

				
0 followers   follows 0 users  
joined 2023 December 20 23:39:44 UTC

				

User ID: 2807

Shrike


				
				
				

				
0 followers   follows 0 users   joined 2023 December 20 23:39:44 UTC

					

No bio...


					

User ID: 2807

The second point is that, irrespective of what people think now, most believing Christians and Jews throughout history believed Genesis was literally true. So there are only three possibilities:

I'm not really sure this is true.

First off, I think we can agree that people can believe incorrect things about the text without the text actually being confusing at all. For instance, it's possible that most believing Christians think the "fruit" in the garden was an apple. Does that reflect poorly on the text? No - the text simply does not say this. We can extend this idea: if a popular version of the text is translated poorly, or ambiguously, and this causes a misconception, does that reflect poorly on the text? No, that can't be right. But (obviously) a lot of translation is itself guided by context. So if the text can be poorly translated for a lack of contextual understanding by the translator without it falling on the fault of the original text, it follows that the text is not at fault for being poorly understood for a lack of contextual understanding.

So Option 4. - the Bible (like any other text) is capable of being misunderstood through no fault of its own - has to be a live option, I think. Getting to another conclusion requires specific work (and there's an interesting discussion to be had if we should assume #2 is correct based on e.g. Matthew 13:10 - 12 etc. but set that aside for a moment).

You could try to salvage your trilemma by arguing that we shouldn't rely on what most people thought, but rather what literate, educated elites (who were more likely to properly understand what the text meant, due to better education, broader experience with literature, being able to read the text in its original language, etc.) Basically, if the people who have no excuse not to misunderstand a text all agree that it should be interpreted one way, it's easier to argue that it's the text's fault if it says something that seems untrue. This is also convenient, since we mostly don't know what most people thought, and have to rely on what educated elites wrote.

With that in mind, is it true that most believing Jews/Jewish educated elites throughout history believed Genesis was literally true? (By "literally true" I mean "7-day young earth creationist or something very similar" - you're welcome to tell me you have a different definition.)

From what I can tell, probably not. If you Google the first Jew to treat Genesis metaphorically, it will give you Philo. But Philo was active before even the Mishnah was compiled, and there's not a lot of commentary on the Torah that predates him, as far as I know. We do know that Philo *wrote against allegory-maxxers" because in his day they were using "it's an allegory bro" to disobey the law:

"For although the seventh day is a lesson to teach us the power which exists in the uncreated God, and also that the creature is entitled to rest from his labours, it does not follow that on that account we may abrogate the laws which are established respecting it, so as to light a fire, or till land, or carry burdens, or bring accusations, or conduct suits at law, or demand a restoration of a deposit, or exact the repayment of a debt, or do any other of the things which are usually permitted at times which are not days of festival." (See On the Migration of Abraham, 91)

So, as far as I can tell on an admittedly cursory investigation into this phenomenon, you're looking at a very spotty historical record and going "all of those people believed X." We don't know what those people believed! Most of what they wrote didn't survive! We do know that Jewish views on Genesis as allegory go back around 2,000 years or so and were widespread enough around that time that it caused social problems (at least in Alexandria).

Furthermore, yo must recall that most people who have lived have lived recently. Google tells me that most Jews who have ever lived lived in the past 300 years; it also tells me that even the very early Jewish commentary we do have was not inclined to interpret, e.g., the 7 days of creation as literal days. So I actually do not see a strong reason to think that most Jews or educated Jews throughout history have believed in what you might call a literal, 7-day-creation interpretation of Genesis. Even if you're wanting to grade on a sort of "most Jews per capita throughout history" basis I'm not sure it helps you much, given the antiquity of Jewish thought on the matter.

I think we could repeat this exercise with Christianity - even very early Christian apologists (Clement, Origin) also did not believe in a literal, 7-day-creation interpretation of Genesis. And most Christians today don't view Genesis as literal (at least in the United States), and, due to the explosion of Christianity, most Christians alive have lived in the past 100 years. (100 years ago, many conservative Christians did not believe in a literal, 7-day creation either - "old earth creationism" was very common). So I do not see a strong reason to think that most Christians or educated Christians throughout history have believed in what you might call a literal, 7-day-creation interpretation of Genesis.

This is all on a pretty cursory bit of research, so I am all ears if you have pushback. But I think it demonstrates the danger of assuming the past [40 years] is representative. Even if I am wrong about most of the above, I'm very much not wrong about that!

I tend to think alien life is far-fetched but this stuff makes for great literature. If you're a science fiction fan and haven't read High Crusade, stop what you are doing right now and get your hands on a copy.

(Admittedly High Crusade is mostly fun for reasons other than theological speculation...)

Evolution essentially implies the opposite.

A little bit more than that, even, evolution says man got to where we are by checks notes killing off the (hominid) competition, improving ourselves in the process.

Now, the vast majority of people like humans, but also wish they were slightly better, and, you know, people look to history to find innovative solutions to their problems...

The Christian cosmology is given in Genesis and takes the form of an Ancient Near East creation myth, not a historical account written with the purpose of giving the curious a scientific understanding of the origins of the universe.

Right, whatever else we know about Genesis, we can be ~completely certain that it was not written solely to appease the scientific curiosity of 21st century Americans. And with modern scholarship we do know that it was written as an Ancient Near East creation myth in form (which wasn't as well understood or appreciated 100 years ago). This obviously doesn't, as a textual matter, settle the question of, e.g., a literal 7-day creation - but I do think that asking the question "how would the ancient Jews have understood this" is a much better starting point than "how would I prefer to understand this"?

It also happens to be better for other areas literary interpretation, which is nice!

Then you only have the bible and it kinda has to be read literally, so as to make your correctness obvious.

You're couching this in sort of absolute terms, as if there's a sort of inexorable logic to the thing, but I actually tend to think these interpretations are more of an accident of history than it seems at first sight. (It seems I am making this argument today!) It's quite possible for conservative evangelical Protestants who takes the Bible very seriously and very literally to be skeptical that a literal interpretation of the Genesis creation story is the best one. Dr. Michael Heiser is my personal go-to example here, but I am sure there are others.

I am a little under-equipped to make a good case for the historical accident thing, but my argument would basically be that

  1. Darwinism and critical readings of Scripture arose about the same time and were both used to attack traditional Christian views of the Bible, ethics, and moral teaching. (It's worth noting that the higher critics were doing their work before Origin of the Species was published, so as far as I can tell there's no necessary link between the two.)
  2. Alternative, non-literal readings of the Genesis creation story, grounded in historical understanding of the text and the Ancient Near East, were underdeveloped at the time due to less knowedge (textually and archeologically), less scholarly attention, worse lingustic skills etc.
  3. Lacking 2 (and of course that any sort of scholarly criticism positing that Genesis was an ANE "creation myth" likely pattern-matched onto 1), conservative Protestants in the United States embraced a "literal" reading of the Bible (not particularly grounded in, say, how ancient Jews would have understood the text) to resist these trends.

Since conservative Protestant's are largely very interested in what the ancient Jews thought (recall that Protestantism is fairly invested in the entire idea of "getting back to the original church" and has some non-trivial claims to making steps in that direction), and given that scholarship has largely shifted to grounds favorable to Christianity (modern scholars are not, by and large, questioning if Jesus or Paul ever really existed, asserting that Pilate wasn't real, postulating late dates for the Gospels, etc.) I think conservative Protestantism is actually primed to move away from YEC literalism as regards the creation story, or at least be less dogmatic about it. If, in some counterfactual history, good, moderate scholarship, solid archeology, and knowledge of ancient texts had arrived before the (misguided) critical scholarship, I think it's quite possible that Protestants would have a much more Catholic-like approach to the entire thing.

Do you honestly think Iran’s leadership would be dumb enough to bomb Washington DC?

You can read what I think right here! TLDR; Iran is not a monolithic faction and some factions might benefit from this action, but perhaps more appealing to you, I think it is good for Iran's leadership to have the capability to bomb Washington, D.C., and one way to suggest that capability without using it might be to talk about it very loudly so that Washington, D.C. will hear of it. Wouldn't you agree?

I’m not a conspiracy theorist I just think Trump is that stupid and so are his advisers.

What would you prefer to refer to this...conjecture about a plan between members of a group to deceive the public for political gain...as?

I wouldn’t be surprised if this is something that came from Israel as a source.

CNN indicates that U.S. SIGINT (which is very good) picked this up directly. Certainly I wouldn't be shocked to learn that they obscured the originating point of the intelligence, nor would I be shocked to learn that it is Israeli, but I don't see any reason to rule out the possibility that the United States is capable of making these sorts of intercepts.

Yes, I caveated that statement specifically with the Evangelical Protestants point, which I thought was important because Skibboleth had mentioned they were disproportionately likely to adhere to YEC, and I wanted to raise a point where they were happy to accept metaphor (and Catholics are not) but maybe I didn't make that clear enough?

I think there's a big difference between "every word of the Bible is literally true" and "unless something it clearly metaphorical it shouldn't be interpreted as such"! I'd be much less inclined to quibble about the latter.

Jesus speaking metaphorically in the gospels about communion is not the same thing as saying "this narrative of events in the Bible is a metaphor."

I agree! But you said "the Bible...speaking metaphorically...blows open the whole endeavor..." so I was responding to that. Perhaps I read you too literally ;)

Nor, as far as I know, do literalists think that the apostle John literally became Mary's son.

Right.

Song of Songs is not metaphorical. It is a collection of romantic poetry that contains descriptive metaphors.

as far as I know the prevailing view amongst literalists is that while it has higher spiritual significance, it is also what it appears to be

Right, I think the dominant Christian interpretation is that not only does it contain metaphors, it is a metaphor for Christ and His church.

does not strip Christ of dignity

Hmm. I'm not sure that it didn't - particularly the part where Christ was crucified in a way specifically intended to rob a human of their dignity:

Let this mind be in you, which was also in Christ Jesus: Who, being in the form of God, thought it not robbery to be equal with God: But made himself of no reputation, and took upon him the form of a servant, and was made in the likeness of men: And being found in fashion as a man, he humbled himself, and became obedient unto death, even the death of the cross. (Philippians 2:5 - 8)

But I am happy to elaborate. Note that I said evolution can do this, not that it does - what I mean is more that it can be used as a tool, or part of a narrative package, to do this. Evolution (in the sense of how species change over time because of genetics by means of selection pressure) as a fact is morally neutral - as facts tend to be. But viewing it as an instrument it is very dangerous morally; I believe that treating humans like livestock, breeding and culling them selectively to achieve desired outcomes, is wrong, and hope you do too. Evolution also (as exemplified by this very forum) calls into question the practical equality of the races, in the sense that it suggests this process in the past may have equipped some races better for some tasks than others. Thus, by itself it's an "infohazard" in the sense that it is information people can do hazardous things with.

What restrains people from doing hazardous things with this knowledge is (partially) the sense that it's morally wrong, and/or a countervailing metanarrative. But the specific materialistic metanarrative that uses purely naturalistic processes - in particular evolution - as the explanation for the existence of all life on earth provides (by itself) no moral guideposts that says "we shouldn't do bad things with this knowledge" and greases the slippery slope by positing that humans are, like other animals, entirely the product of natural processes.

Christianity, following the path of Judaism, insists on inherent dignity to all humans as made in God's image regardless of their personal capabilities. (Interestingly it also indicates that animals and their well-being are worthy of moral consideration, but that's a tangent!) Replacing this with a purely materialistic metanarrative couched in evolutionary terms provides the means to treat humans like livestock, or call into question racial tolerance, but also at the same time removes any countervailing religious motive not to do these things.

Please note: I'm not claiming something like "people who aren't religious want to genocide other people" or anything like that. I'm just saying that materialism by itself can't do the work of Christianity (or any other religion that emphasizes human dignity) in providing a metanarrative that protects humans from the implications of evolution.

Hopefully that makes sense!

What’s this kinetic superiority I’m presently not seeing according to you?

The U.S. and Israel have been able to strike deep within Iran, is your position that they couldn't effectively strike the 500-mile logistics tail necessary to invade Israel, or that Iran can succeed at destroying a state through conventional bombing despite ~every other attempt at doing this failing completely?

It isn’t some kind of historical tragedy that’s going to replayed with different results.

Right, because Iran isn't going to "shift to total economic mobilization and launch a ground invasion on Israel." If they did attempt this, history would replay as farce.

"Every single Word in Scripture is literally true" is a strawman caricature that ~nobody in real life holds. For instance, I've never met anyone who thinks that Song of Solomon 4:12 -14 is speaking entirely literally and with no metaphorical imagery at all about a very secure garden with a pomegranate-and-spice orchard.

One also wonders why you think that Biblical literalists of all people would believe Scripture would always be straightforward and could never be a source of confusion given the literal interpretation of passages such as 1 Corinthians 1:22 - 24 ("we preach Christ crucified, to the Jews a stumbling block and to the Greeks foolishness"), or, say, Mark 13:14 ("let the reader understand" is clearly saying "I'm not spelling it out for you").

The ways Christians actually work to interpret Scripture and the debates about how best to do that can actually be pretty interesting and I can point you to some examples if you like. I'm sure there are others on here who could do an even better job.

To concede that creationism is wrong is to concede that the Bible is either wrong (and thus not inerrant, which blows open the whole endeavor) or speaking metaphorically (which also blows open the whole endeavor).

This isn't true at all - pretty much everyone agrees that the Bible speaks metaphorically (might I point you to Song of Songs? Or Christ's statement regarding His body and blood, which most Protestants - particularly Evangelical Protestants who are likely to be YECers - agree is metaphorical?) It's just a question of when it is best interpreted that way.

Hydro is correct that it's viewed as a trojan horse.

Do you seriously think if Iran was out to destroy Israel it wouldn’t impose total economic mobilization on the entire country and shift to 100% war time production of the economy?

I do not think that Iran would win this war if they tried to do this. The plan you are outlining is "mobilize hundreds of thousands of conscripts, throw together a logistical tail that previously did not exist, and drive more than 500 miles through neutral countries to attack an enemy with a considerable technological edge, essentially uncontested air superiority, and nuclear weapons."

What happens if you try this is that Israel bombs your supply lines with JDAMs and your hundreds of thousands of conscripts desert in the middle of Iraq. If you don't find that compelling, can I remind you that Iran has actually already tried this exact strategy against Iraq, except at a time when they had the technological edge, and the result was that they stalled out and had to make peace?

I'm curious if any actual creationists on this form can chime in on why evolution is problematic from a theological perspective.

I assume you mean a young-Earth creationist? You can combine creationism with evolution - "God created Adam de novo but evolution is real" or "God created the first life and from thence it evolved" or "Evolution is real but God guided the process" are all forms of creationism.

Not a YECer exactly, but hope you don't mind my taking a stab at explaining anyway.

Why are some Christians so intent on rejecting evolution?

Because evolution is very often used instrumentally to attack Christianity as a tool. You are far from the only person who sees no division between Christ and evolution, but for the past 100 years almost everyone who went after Christ wielded evolution as a tool. Disproving key aspects of the materialistic narrative would be a tremendous narrative coup for Christianity.

Secondarily because many Christians (correctly) believe that evolution can be a cognitive infohazard that strips the human of dignity. As you allude to:

Another possibility related to this one is that evolution makes the distinction between human and animal souls much more artificial, undermining the anthropocentrism that is so important to Christianity (and many other faiths too).

Better understanding of Darwinian thought and better understanding of genetics led directly to eugenics as a movement. Today, after World War Two, "eugenics is bad" is (fortunately) a key part of our cultural narrative, and one many Christians believe in. But "eugenics is bad," particularly in a strong form, is almost unbelievable without attributing dignity to the human person, which genetics does not provide by itself. Thus, although many people have no problem condemning eugenics just because it's the trendy thing to do, conservative Christianity in America (which is a reaction to the eugenics-friendly mainstream Protestantism that was popular during the Progressive era, which was, in the eyes of conservative American Christians, focused on social reform at the expense of things like Biblical truth) is aware that embracing Darwin carries with it a danger of embracing eugenics: this happened to their sister denominations!

Yoshi claims that we don't have any direct evidence of evolution, but we literally do

Christians who get into these sorts of arguments often use "evolution" to mean "the theory that life arose spontaneously and through neo/Darwinian means spread and evolved into all of the life forms we see today" instead of "genetics is real." Sometimes you'll see the phrase "macroevolution" being tossed around to make the distinction. (Going back up to my first paragraph, YECers don't deny that moth coloration can change via selection pressure, they deny "macroevolution.")

I personally cannot really endorse a belief system that is incompatible with both free inquiry into these types of questions, and unwilling to examine the evidence from the real world (God's more true bible), which a big part of why I've completely stopped going to church.

Let me just encourage you that even hardcore YEC-types would, almost to a man, agree that you can be a Christian and believe in evolution. I do not think "Christianity" is incompatible with free inquiry into these types of questions, and my (personal speculation, perhaps overfitting my own life experience) is that Christianity in the United States is going to be more open to these sorts of questions going forward, particularly now that the Atheism Wars have cooled off some and the next round of the Eugenics Wars isn't going to need to rely on "macroevolution" to justify what it wants to do. It's unfortunate, but yes, even Christians are prone to allowing adversarial narratives to shape their beliefs, and as the adversarial narratives change I think you will see less of a defensive crouch in these areas.

I don't think the purpose of going to church is to find a place where people agree with you on everything. I think it's to seek God, to learn from His Word, and edify other believers and mutually encourage them to pursue holiness and good works. It is guaranteed that other members in your congregation will be wrong about some things (even theological ones!) but I don't think that has to be a barrier to pursuing the goals that church is established for (and if your fellow brothers in Christ are doing that, I am sorry to hear it; I have not had that experience and would extend an invite to you if you're in my area; feel free to DM.)

Linking to an earlier comment of mine you may have already seen that might flesh this out a bit more, and point towards a really cool instance where following the (scientific) truth to where it leads doesn't have to be at odds with Christian faith.

Why does it "have" to be BS? Do you deny that dirty bombs are a threat, or that Iran possesses the technical means to create them, or what? Do you assert that pre-Trump-administration warnings about dirty bombs were attempts to make people lose faith in our institutions?

Hmm. In my experience, sanctification is definitely "in the picture" in Protestant churches. Even the Westminster Confession - which is Reformed (and thus their soteriology is approximately 100% God, 0% Man) - has a section on it.

And even the Reformed see it as "part of salvation" - "They who are effectually called and regenerated...are further sanctified...and...quickened and strengthened, in all saving graces, to the practice of true holiness, without which no man shall see the Lord."

With the caveat that my knowledge of Protestantism is not exhaustive, if the Reformed are talking about it, pretty much everyone else is, with the possible exception (on the one hand) of liberal Protestants who have gone all-in on religion as a social club and (on the other) of low-church or non-denominational Protestants, who definitely think sanctification is important in the sense of holy living, but may not lean very heavily on the term as a theological concept.

The Holiness movement (not exactly an inconsequential branch of Protestantism) is all-in on sanctification, and their teaching was very influential beyond Methodism (probably the most obvious example of a Holiness denomination), particularly in the United States.

I do think that there is a difference in Protestant and Catholic/Orthodox conceptions of salvation - because Protestants are, on the sliding scale, more focused on "grace by faith, not by works" their conceptions of salvation are more about orthodoxy. Catholics and the Orthodox, it seems to me, place more emphasis on orthopraxy in their soterological doctrine. (Note that I wouldn't agree that Protestants place less emphasis on holiness - rather, they often resort to (depending on the denomination) sort of awkward phraseology to deal with how it interfaces with salvation. For instance, the question of "if someone wasn't 'really' saved" will often come up in hypotheticals as a way of articulating the problem of professing Christians living in unrepentant sin.)

At the risk of being somewhat reductionist, I often think a bit too much is sometimes made of the doctrinal differences between the Protestant and Catholic/Orthodox churches in these matters. There's a tendency to evaluate them as purely theological differences through a philosophical or aesthetic lens, a pure-mind divergence on the meaning of the text and tradition. But Catholic and Orthodox focus on orthopraxy seems to me like an almost-necessary adaptation given that Catholicism (and, to a lesser degree, Orthodoxy) was attempting administer a uniform Christian faith across a variety of very different cultures that were generally largely illiterate and structured according to a hierarchical pattern. Something like Protestantism is, I would say, follows naturally (not necessarily inevitably) from widespread literacy and lower-cost texts (and I think you can even see this in Catholicism!)

Elaborate, please.

I agree with you that the beneficiaries of the story coming out are war hawks. It's not impossible that it is made up wholesale. But

  1. I don't think that the Iranian government is a unified whole. Some of them might be willing to gamble or terminally focused on revenge. (Perhaps the leaks are even a U.S. way of trying to goad the more level-headed Iranians into doing some internal pruning.)
  2. Threatening to bomb an enemy capitol (including by being recorded developing credible plans to do so) is actually very helpful to Iran, since it gives them something they can trade away in negotiations and something they can use to make the U.S. think twice about escalation. So far the U.S. has held most of the cards. A credible threat of retaliation on the eve of anticipated U.S. retaliation might aid their goals.

Yes, I think so, although as you alluded to earlier there are probably going to be a few Protestants who are going to be all "no no, that's how it works," at least as regards the narrow phrasing you put forward.

Yeah sorry to derail you there, the description just didn't ring true to me. The point about how people's behavior in little things matters I very much agree with.

In both of these cases the question is one of soteriology. Neither (generally speaking) Protestants nor Catholics disagree that a single sin could damn you. Neither Protestants nor Catholics disagree that any number of sins can be forgiven. The big question here is about what is necessary for a Christian to remain in a state of saving grace.

Protestants (at least from conservative denominations) are not running around objecting to the idea that a single sin can damn you; in fact they are probably more likely to have a hardcore stance on this given that the Catholic church teaches that the culpability and guilt of an action can be reduced and that there is a distinction between venial and mortal sins. And of course Calvinist Protestants (which, again, are in the Augustinian tradition) teach that damnation or salvation is not based on human works and therefore humans can be damned without necessarily committing a sinful act, due to imputed guilt.

The Protestant objection (broadly) is really an objection to the Catholic understanding of how salvation works - Protestants aren't typically going to divide up sins into venial and mortal and say that one of them is a dealbreaker for God and one isn't, and in many denominations they are going to be less keen on the idea that a special sacrament is needed to reconcile one with God (although there's something of a division among Protestants on this).

Sure, and I think that's part of making contextual sense of the Old Testament to conservative Christians.

One of the perennial arguments of Protestants against Catholics is the idea that someone can be damned for one sin.

Protestants are generally quite comfortable with this idea, to the point where some Protestant denominations are quite comfortable saying people are damned for committing zero sins at all. This is actually in line with older Catholic (Augustinian) thought on the matter.

I think the actual idea in dispute is tied to priestly mediation.

I’m still just curious why intellectually many literalists go for what seems to me to be a lot of unnecessary epicycles when there seem to be easier ways to accommodate 6 day creation like the aforementioned Omaphalos Hypothesis or General Relativity.

I think to win them over, alternative explanations for Genesis have to provide a compelling reason why the explanation makes good (con)textual sense. That's what people want, a theory that makes sense of the text without devaluing it or seeming like cope. I do think that's happening now, as ancient Near Eastern texts are better understood and the scholarship surrounding them popularized. The question YECers are weak to is "is modern science the best interpretive lens through which we should understand the Word of God as given to ancient Israelites?" and it's easier to pose that question when you know something about the ancient Israelites. But (as with most things) I think public knowledge about these things moves much more slowly than the forward edge of scholarship.