It reads similarly to Hammurabi's prologue (and serves a similar function as the prologue of the Pentateuch) and other ANE texts. Hammurabi's code was only rediscovered in 1901 so prior interpretations literally could not make that connection. As for the history of interpretation, a super-literal understanding of Genesis has always been one interpretation among others.
Which I do think happens. Plenty of turbo-autists are Christians.
It is a de novo trait.
If you aren't familiar with what that means technically, this can be misleading. What happened here was a rearrangement of DNA; this mutation didn't write new DNA, it reordered existing genetic material. That's why it is called a transposition event. In all likelihood this exact mutation had happened before in the past, it just didn't stick; the reason it is such an interesting example of natural selection is that when it happened this time, it was advantageous due to changes in environmental conditions, and became common.
Speciation is sort of a social construct anyway, it's not like God (or, uh, the Platonic Laws of Evolution?) establish a hard-and-fast cutoff point at which two species are "different." The natural one is "can they reproduce" but coyotes and wolves can interbreed and have fertile offspring; so can polar and grizzly bears. Meanwhile dogs cannot (realistically) all interbreed with each other.
I'm not saying there isn't a productive argument to be had here, just that "we've observed speciation" doesn't by itself actually tell you much about gene expression.
Good thoughts.
Oddly unbecoming of a deity.
I think all of the breath that is spent on how the "OT God" is different from the "NT God" cannot elide this fact. The New Testament is much closer to our modern culture and may be more intuitive to understand, but the more you learn about the other creation myths of other cultures that Genesis is parallel with, the more you realize that the radical moral revolution wrought by Christianity really does go back to the ancient Israelites and their sacred text, with its moral inversion of the brutality and callousness of their neighbors.
if Jesus was a big phenomenon in life there would be non-christian sources about it
This is a recycled version of an old Roman argument against Christ: "God would never be born as an obscure peasant."
Setting aside the fact you're wrong about this (there are also non-Jewish sources, some of them relatively early - Mara bar Serapion being a fun one, Tacitus being a pretty uncontroversial one), this is also an isolated demand for rigor. For instance, my understanding is that there are no contemporaneous accounts naming Pompeii as being destroyed by Vesuvius, even though we have an eyewitness account of the event occurring. We ~know they exist, we just haven't found them because they haven't survived (or, hopefully, haven't been found yet.) We know most writing from this time no longer exists. The presence of no early writing would not by itself be good evidence for the non-existence of Christ, any more than it would be for the non-existence of Pompeii being destroyed by Vesuvius; the fact that we actually do have very early writings referencing Christ is positive evidence in favor of Christ's existence.
We must keep in mind that Christianity was pretty obscure during the First Century and the lack of mention of Christ by some outside sources means little. While it's impossible to know for sure, Google suggests estimates of about 10,000 Christians worldwide in 100 AD - a fraction of a percent of the population of the Roman empire. Just as a fun comparison, that's on the low-end for the estimates of the population of Pompeii alone. (High-end estimates run higher than the place I live in now.) So an entire town larger in population than every Christian alive at the time can get Thanos-snapped out of existence and we have zero contemporary letters saying anything like "I'm really sorry your cousin was at Pompeii when it was completely buried by a volcano" or anything like that. I find it remarkable that we have ~any early textual evidence of an unpopular rural religious movement that originated in a minor Roman province that was completely trashed by a massive war a few decades after its origin.
I also am (sadly) skeptical that these sorts of sources would move the needle of this debate much. Imagine tomorrow that we found a source that referred to Christ, written in Jerusalem around 30 AD. Either
- It's clearly Christian and thus you would discount it as Christian
- It's not Christian and thus almost certainly wouldn't say anything we're not already getting from early sources like Josephus - Christ was a religious leader who was supposed to perform miracles who was crucified by the Romans.
For obvious reasons there's not going to be many people who are writing letters saying "Christ is definitely a miracle worker, the Son of God who was slain for the sins of the world, He has risen from the empty tomb - I'm still a pagan/non-Christian Jew btw." Realistically that sort of account looks like Paul's writings. The Jewish religious authorities in Jerusalem might have written something similar (in defiance of Stringer Bell's dictum) but due to the sack of Jerusalem it's not surprising that we don't have those papers.
Even if we imagine a #3 option - "I was there the entire time and none of it was true" - that's hardly an impeachable source or a deal-breaker for Christians - they are just going to note that the Gospel texts say that Christ was falsely accused and note that such a text confirms that Christ was known as a miracle-worker. But we don't have such a source, and the best neutral sources gel on the basics of Christ being a religious leader/miracle-worker who was executed by Pilate.
The Talmud places Jesus in 75BC which creates more problems than it solves.
My understanding is that the Talmud has a number of stories that may mention Christ, some of which correspond to the historical timeframe better than others, and some of which may be about someone else. As I mentioned previously, it's possible the Talmud's stories are written as a response to Christian texts or oral traditions, not preserving their own.
if we're still talking about what historians believe
Evidently we aren't, since most historians think Josephus did mention Christ.
Yes, I think this is probably correct.
I think the idea of a "Q" text was probably embraced in part because it seemed to embarrass Christians - the theory goes back to the early 1900s - but now that later dates for the Gospels are essentially impossible to argue for, "Q" looks more and more like "contemporaneous notes taken of Christ's parables"
maybe you just mean some sort of formatting similarity? But the content could not be more different.
Yeah, I think that is (at least part of - this cannot rule out other meanings; the Bible can speak truthfully in layers) what is going on in Genesis 1 - 2. The seven-day cycle (AIUI) mirrors the numerology used by other nearby cultures for temple consecration, the conversation leading to the creation of man, followed by that creation told twice - apparently a motif that crops up enough that some writers theorize it was a trope or genre convention at the time. But the story it tells within that form or using those touchstones is very different: God is the sole Creator, not warring it out with other cosmic figures; man is a gardener, not a slave, intended from the start to bear the image of God, not rely on idols and god-kings to appeal to heaven; all of Creation is good, not birthed from some primordial cataclysm or complex and costly magical spell by but the Word of an omnipotent Creator.
Is that how it's supposed to work?
To be honest, I don't actually get much of a feeling. I really should have said that it's trite. Then you have kids and it's less so. Or at least that is my experience!
maybe making whatever peace I can with the knowledge I'm on my own is the point of hearing basically nothing?
That doesn't seem impossible to me. It sounds to me like you're trusting God - ultimately the most we can trust God with is our soul, and those who trust in Him will not be put to shame.
I don't expect cavemen to be writing equations they don't understand on the walls and bowing down to them much less propagating them beyond that cave.
YEP.
It's also rather interesting considering "acting in this way is what they're expecting, it's just going to come in that way that really, really smart people who are trying to show off how powerful they actually are tend to do" tends to just be the way God operates/a feature consistent with His character in ways I wouldn't ordinarily expect. (Most organic pantheon seem to lack a god of younger brothers [the only one I can think of is Loki and that's really not a central example].)
Can you elaborate? I think I see where you are going, but would love to know more.
It certainly implies a God that is ultimately pleased with humanity, and something none of the other religions really seem to have figured out
Yeah, in no small part thanks to the Mottepoasting I have been doing, I've been learning a bit more about the comparative mythology that is the context for Genesis, and Genesis is very different from other, similar stories, where the gods are violent, and make men to be literal slaves. In Genesis God makes all humans His image-bearers, not just kings or ritual idols. That makes us all responsible for, as you put it, doing what we think would please Him.
It seems... annoyingly perfect, especially since it's not actually possible to figure out when it ends.
Yes, it seems possible that the Good News arrived practically at the first moment it could actually begin to spread around the world, and ultimately will be known throughout the vast majority of human existence in this universe.
I am not a believing Christian anymore, in large part, because I find these evangelical arguments unconvincing.
Right, and (as an evangelical) I am skeptical of these arguments because I am skeptical they are the best way to understand the Bible. Not just because of the extratextual evidence, but also because I don't think the best way to look at the text is without context. I certainly think it's a mistake to take them as the only way to be a Christian, or to let them get between you and God.
It seems to me that a lot of people from evangelical backgrounds who leave the faith often still find the evangelical premises convincing - hence the entire train of logic that says "the text must be literal or wrong" and when people decide it's not entirely literal, they leave the faith. My argument is that that's an false dilemma (particularly with, e.g., the Creation story) as Christians have argued for upwards of a thousand years.
maybe it was specifically meant as a figure of speech for a target audience that didn't consist solely of turbo-autists.
Before you have kids, God saying that you are His child is sort of a nice, warm, fuzzy thing. After you have kids, when you've said something like "we will eat dinner when we get back home from the grocery store" without also explaining specifically and at length that dinner does not appear out of thin air fully formed and also that you need to use the bathroom because these things go without saying and now you are still getting groceries out of the car and your kids are demanding to know where dinner is and you need to pee, you come to see it as being true in a much more funny way.
Anyway, I like your comment. I think the symbolism in Scripture - and other religions, too - displays a better understanding of how to communicate with humans than the sort of rationalist demands for extreme clarity. And the historical timing of Christianity arising is so interesting - if you ever write up another comment touching on that, I'd love to be tagged!
I don't think this is really right at all.
I'm passionate about this stuff, perhaps in part because I've done a bit of writing that is intentionally cryptic or contains hidden references myself, and thus your post comes close to striking a nerve, and perhaps because you didn't really acknowledge the last time I responded to you pushing back on some of this. So I'm gonna over-reply to this, hopefully you enjoy reading the wall of text as much as I enjoyed writing it.
- This sort of assumes that a single writing could be equally clear to everyone in all times and places. I don't think this is possible - some people and places are always going to be more literate than others. Arguing that God isn't real because He won't square a circle isn't persuasive, at least not to me. There's also a hint of future discounting going on here - generally speaking, our knowledge of Scripture is increasing. If over the next 100 years the questions about the meaning of Genesis are entirely resolved by new scholarship, new archeological discoveries, etc. and then history continues to roll on, it will quickly become true (by cosmic timescales) that the number of humans who were ever troubled or confused by this passage is vanishingly small, which would obviate your argument unless your argument is that it should always at all times be equally clear to all people (squaring a circle.)
- It ascribes human logic to God without justification. "Therefore it stands to reason he would write in the clearest way possible" why? Because you said so? I don't think anyone on this board, if they read something that seemed deliberately cryptic written by an intelligent person, or (let's say) a hypothetical ASI, would have any trouble understanding that this was not evidence against the intelligence or moral character of that person, because humans do not always write clearly and sometimes that is by design. Likewise, if we have trouble understanding something written by an intelligent person (or, even more trivially, have trouble with a math problem) have no trouble understanding that sometimes ease is opposed to the purposes of a text - even something as clear as math is not necessarily easy to find a solution for.
- It is contrary to the actual practice, overt teaching, and historical context of Scripture. We know God is okay with tricking people, or at a minimum not informing them about things. Christ preaches in parables (and explicitly says that He does so because those He is speaking to are not meant to know the "mysteries of the kingdom of heaven"), Matthew refers to the cryptic prophecies of Daniel with a "let the reader understand" rather than a clear explanation, Proverbs 25:2 says plainly "It is the glory of God to conceal a thing: but the honour of kings is to search out a matter." This is not only revealed in the words of the text, but also in how it is written: the Bible is full of puns, wordplay, references, humor, which always come with a risk of misunderstanding (some people are better at getting jokes than others.) Rather than letting the Bible and its context reveal how to interpret itself, you are going to impose your own preferred analytical method on it. That is just a bad way to read and understand any literature. You don't have to be a Christian to buy that.
- It is poor psychology. If you just want a clear and concise set of guidelines, the Bible actually gives them to you. Christ says the law and the prophets hang on two clear commandments ("Thou shalt love the Lord thy God with all thy heart, and with all thy soul, and with all thy mind...Thou shalt love thy neighbour as thyself.") But humans actually do not find to-do post-its compelling. Humans enjoy solving puzzles. And the Bible is written for the whole person (including the subconscious self) - to do that, to really provoke the whole human, you need to engage the whole human. So the Bible is full of little puzzles to absorb the mind and striking imagery that its readers can relate to. When God wants you to understand Himself, He paints a picture of Isaac on the altar to ask you "what sort of Father would do that to His Son?" This is infinitely more compelling to the whole man than, say, beaming an improved version of the U.S. legal code onto the Capitol steps or something, partially because the whole man thinks in more than language, it has thoughts deeper than sentences and reasons in ways that cannot be captured in mere syllogistic logic. Scripture understands this and speaks in ways that move the whole man. (By the way, I don't think this understanding of the need to use things more profound than syllogism is unique to Judeo-Christian religion.)
- It is a bad theory of good literature. I don't think I need to elaborate on this much, the straightforward post-it note is not compelling reading.
- This is also a general argument against believing almost anything tucked away in here. If reality is sufficiently messy that it can be confusing, the Bible being confusing at times presents little problem if the Bible truly reflects reality. But if reality is actually very easy to apprehend, then in any area where people are divided on a question (vaccines, evolution, the shape of the Earth, etc.) that division is itself evidence against any given controversial position being true. But sometimes things that are hard to understand are still true!
Finally, a thought experiment. Suppose that God wants to write a humorous send-up of local Babylonian religious practices. He uses local idiom, puns, and references to do this, because that is how humor works and because that is what will be effective in accomplishing His purpose. And because enough texts from the time survive, and because we have access to them, we can know all of this, but it's not in the text itself because the text gets translated and doesn't have self-referential explanatory notes for things that would be obvious as originally written (for instance, "Babel is wordplay on Babylon"). This means it won't be "written in the clearest way possible" when it is translated, especially as references to local Babylonian religious practices will grow less comprehensible as those practices die out even if the text was crystal-clear at the time. Then let's stipulate that scholars all know this and publish free papers explaining all of the humor in the text. How is the text supposed to make the reader go to your web browser, type in "Google," and perform the word search that would quickly explain to you everything that is going on in that passage? Is failing to understand this really a failure of the text, or is that on the reader?
There is only one method an author has at his disposal to overcome the ignorance of readers if he wants to include referential humor, puns, etc. and still hopes to survive translation, and that is by making his story cryptic, intriguing, or compelling enough to be worth digging into. And given these discussions, I would say Scripture is pretty good at this.
Yes, I think you're right - we don't really disagree. Thanks for letting me hash it out, though!
Suppose there actually was a big event that 50 people witnessed,
Interestingly you get numbers in the Gospel, including for events a lot larger than "50." As we will see, there are extra-Biblical reasons to think that accounts of Christ's miracles were widespread, or at least not fringe.
none of the things Jesus did could have many more original witnesses otherwise we would have non-christian sources about it
We do have non-Christian sources about it! I think the reason we don't have more is that the First Jewish War resulted in Rome scouring Palestine, destroying Jerusalem, and generally overturning Jewish society, with the typical negative consequences for any local records that might otherwise have survived, including Roman and Temple records in Jerusalem. (Another possible reason could in theory be that people who saw Christ's miracles and wrote about them afterwards were disproportionately likely to be Christians although there are some counterexamples.)
So, if we're looking at sources outside of the New Testament for the "local view" of the time, our best surviving sources are, from what I understand, Josephus and the Talmudic references to Christ. And both sources reference the idea that Christ was a miracle-worker, so it seems reasonable to assume that there was a preexisting narrative along these lines. (There is some dispute over the accuracy of Josephus' account - although new work suggests that due to a missing word or two the text we have is best taken as much less laudatory of Christ than it has been understood to be in the past - but even reconstructions of the text minus the parts believed by some to be Christian insertions reference some idea of miraculous works - or, in the case of the Aramaic text, the resurrection.) Note that I am not claiming that Josephus was a Christian, just that Josephus is about as good a text as we have, and he seems familiar with the idea that Christ worked miracles.
The Talmudic treatment of Christ is very interesting, since from what I understand it is broadly in line with what the New Testament records: the Jewish religious elites do not deny that Christ is a miracle worker, but rather deny that the miracles come from God. It is possible that the Talmudic writers were not drawing on 1st century Jewish traditions of the Christ but rather responding to the Gospel narrative itself (in other words, instead of preserving an independent oral tradition, making up a new one to rebut the Christian narrative) but if that is the case, it seems curious that they frame Christ as real and possessing power rather than simply denying that He ever existed.
a completely impossible depiction of the cleansing of the temple
Not sure what you are referencing here, since my understanding is that historians agree this depiction references a real event, and there are in fact extra-Biblical reasons, leaning on rabbinic traditions of the time, to believe the temple practices Christ condemns were new, instituted around 30 AD (which explains the event). The debate is over whether or not Christ performed it twice, or whether John placed his account of the cleansing of the temple towards the beginning of Christ's ministry for thematic reasons (not necessarily an unusual technique by the standards of the time.)
Even if you don't buy the cleansing of the temple (for whatever reason) the fact that rabbinic sources point to a controversial change to allow a market in the temple around 30 AD and the fact that Gospel writers record Christ doing something about it suggests that the Gospel authors had good working knowledge of what was happening in Jerusalem at the time.
And Paul never met Jesus.
Paul explicitly claims to have met Jesus. This is why he switched teams!
We don't have Jewish commentaries on Genesis from anywhere close, chronologically, to when Genesis was written and/or compiled so we don't actually know for sure one way or the other how people interpreted it "back then." The Genesis text was originally written (at a minimum) hundreds years before Philo. Thus, the surviving texts from Philo's era are in conversation with Greek ideas, rather than in conversation with the Babylonians and surrounding Canaanites, as Genesis is.
My understanding is that ANE scholars tend to think the entire question of "is this supposed to be literal or metaphor" is a misunderstood imposition on the creation texts of the time, which were serving in a liturgical role with an orthopraxic function. They come to this conclusion in part by cross-referencing other surviving works of the same time and era. For instance, in Hammurabi's introduction to his famous code, he says that he was called by the gods to establish justice. Now, again, we may not know for sure how people at the time understood this, but it seems quite probable that nobody at the time understood that to be saying "I, Hammurabi, literally talked to a deity" but rather that Hammurabi is invoking the divine cosmic order of the time and his position in it as justification for his laws. This does not mean the text is metaphorical - you'd really get in trouble for stealing, people at the time likely did believe in the gods and the cosmic system referenced in the text, and the actual conquests mentioned in the text are real.
And it's not even difficult to get this from a gloss of Hammurabi's code as translated into English, even without familiarity with the background knowledge, but for some reason when it comes to Genesis people sometimes pretend it's impossible in principle for the text to switch between genres in a similar fashion, and to have been understood to have been doing so at the time by its intended audience.
One thing we can be pretty certain of is that Genesis was positing a different cosmology (one that elevated man relative to other creation myths at the time, in which man was created to be the slaves of the gods), that it is full of send-ups or criticisms of other religions at the time, and that it and the rest of the Pentateuch successfully preserved Jewish culture in a way that dramatically outperformed their competition.
This is well within living memory: Frier gives a 15 year old a 34% chance of living to 55 and a 26% chance of living to 60, so if Mark is writing in 70 AD we'd expect plenty of surviving witnesses from an incident in 30 AD.
Also, the Gospel's don't spring up in a vacuum. It looks like some scholars believe there was a Q-text, or portions thereof, as early as the 30s, although late-daters will put it closer to Mark in the timeline. Even if you don't believe in a Q-text, or late-date it, Paul is writing around 50 CE (so a majority of 20 year olds would have survived the intervening 20 years) and Paul references oral traditions that are older than his letters and likely date to the 30s or 40s.
The Gospels could have been written in 34 AD and that wouldn't by itself rule out lying. But they also could have been written in 234 AD and that by itself wouldn't change the fact of relatively early attestation.
This isn't really what you find in the text if you look at what is believed to be the oldest portions of the Old Testament text (very unambiguously pre-Christian).
For instance, the Song of Moses is believed to be early, and it uses the term šēḏ (~demon) to refer to other deities and says that God allocated the portions of the other gods (look at the earliest texts on Deuteronomy 32:8 from the Septuagint or Dead Sea Scrolls) - in other words, it assigned preeminence to the Hebrew God. You see something similar in the Song of the Sea ("Who among the gods is like you, Lord?")
It is true the Elohim is a plural construction for spiritual entities, but it does not seem to only refer to deities as we think of them; see 1 Samuel 28 where Saul consults with a medium who says "I saw gods [Elohim] ascending out of the earth...An old man cometh up; and he is covered with a mantle" (this is identified by Saul as Samuel).
(As an aside, this entire scene is fantastic, very primordial-horror feel, of the sort of feel Eggers would put into a movie, or something.)
Protestants, by dint of their theological commitments, can't appeal to some spiritual authority other than the Bible. There's no clergy to dictate the correct interpretation. Everything comes down to the judgment of the individual in interpreting scripture.
This isn't actually how Protestants view things! Confessional Protestantism has creeds (including some they share with Catholics), catechism, and confessions they wrote at church councils. Even nondenominational churches will have statements of faith you have to sign to be a member, and those will be appealed to if you teach something you derived from Scripture that is contrary to them. Members of all of these groups will also appeal to traditional church teaching. It is true that other spiritual authorities are not considered infallible in Protestantism in the same way the Bible is, but that doesn't mean they do not exist.
The idea of the role of the judgment of the individual in interpreting Scripture isn't that all interpretations are equally valid, it is that individual members are supposed to do the personal work to come to correct conclusions about Scripture (and perhaps more importantly, let Scripture and the Holy Spirit shape their own mind through personal study.)
Quick example on this - the New Testament isn't really clear on whether credobaptism is the normative form of baptism or not. Thus, among Protestants, there is a lively debate over which direction Scripture goes, but any time that debate starts up in earnest each side is going to go back to church tradition (typically as early as possible) to bolster their arguments, referencing things like the Didache, early church fathers, and archeological inscriptions to make their case.
This isn't actually that dissimilar from the Catholic line - the Catholic line that binding councils cannot contradict Scripture. Protestants would say "our binding councils do not contradict Scripture" and then argue over whether or not that is true (Catholics will instead argue about what the council means.)
Does that make sense?
Saying the Bible is the literal and inerrant word of God introduces its own host of problems, but it forecloses a bunch of ideas that theologically conservative Protestants would prefer not to entertain.
Right, I think this is correct.
If Genesis 1, e.g., is a metaphor, that allows the possibility that other Biblical narratives are also metaphorical. You can argue this or that particular passage is/isn't a metaphor, but in the absence of some authority like the Pope it's just your interpretation against mine.
This I think is not the best way to look at this. Some interpretations are actually better than others - this is as true for Shakespeare as it is for Scripture. And I think all else being equal Christians today are better equipped to interpret Scripture than they were in, say, 1820. Thus it is far from clear (contra what YECers like to say) that the options are only "7-day creation or anything can be a metaphor!" You can say "the understanding of the text in its original context is the best interpretive guide besides Scripture itself for understanding the text" and then you can argue "in the original context of the Genesis creation arc nobody would take it literally any more than Christ's audience would have understood His parables to be literal" and in parallel argue "in the original context of the teachings of Christ, people would have understood His teaching on [e.g.] divorce as a morally binding statement." Now, this sort of argument might be wrong but an argument like this is not inherently narratively brittle, it is internally consistent. Does that make sense?
Maybe a better way of phrasing what I am trying to get at is that I don't think there is a widely held view that Song of Songs is only a metaphor.
Ah, yes, this makes sense. I do think Christians (and feel free to point out if I do this!) sometimes say "only a metaphor" when what they really mean is "not moral instruction" - so for instance ahhh recreating Song of Songs isn't something people are being instructed to do literally. (Similarly, Ezekiel cooking over cow dung is not a sign we must do the same.) This could lead to people saying "it's a metaphor" but I think you're not wrong to say "well it's love poetry."
Great effort was put into massacring adjacent heresies, Catharism proceeded along similar lines and was put down hard. Only later on was there a shift towards everything indefensible being a metaphor. It wasn't known in advance what was supposed to be metaphor and what was supposed to be fact, until the real facts were established.
Very much not true; the debate over whether or not Genesis was entirely literal likely predates Christianity (Philo being an early Jewish writer who discusses whether all aspects of Genesis were literal) and early Christian apologists debated this question roughly a millennia before the Cathars were "put down hard." This debate really is one of those "the more things change, the more they stay the same" things.
Genesis 1 and 2 even preserve two differing accounts.
That's likely not what's going on, actually – or, at a minimum, probably not all that is going on. (It's a little surprising to me the source you cite seems completely unaware of both the context in other Mesopotamian stories and scholarship surrounding them but also in the neighboring chapters of the book...) The doubled accounts is a common theme in ANE literature (for instance, we see a seeming "double creation" of man account in the Atraḫasīs). Moreover, in Genesis 1 - 2 specifically, the "doubled account" of the creation of man mirrors the seemingly "double" chronology in Genesis 1 - 11. In Genesis 4 and 5, and again in Genesis 10 and 11, we are presented with double genealogies, wherein the first genealogy introduces a big picture idea and the second genealogy; the genealogy of the first man in Genesis 1 and 2 has the same movement, from an unnamed man to a named Adam. (See Richard Hess, "Genesis 1 - 2 in its Literary Context"). You also see this structure in the Atraḫasīs, I think, with Mami making man with blood mixed with clay in the first account and the second account detailing that she made 14 people from 14 different pieces of clay and designing the human race to be male and female.
Obviously you can't rule out multiple sources being drawn from with this sort of analysis, but it does show that the choices were serving a unified literary purpose rather than cobbling together disparate texts semi-coherently. And the fact that you see this in other ANE literature (I'm having trouble grokking Enki and Ninmah but I think there's a similar pattern there too, starting with the wide-shot creation of man and then the detailed subsequent creation, during a drunken bet, of a number of infirm men) suggests to me a genre-pattern.
As a personal note, I've been reading Homer lately and you see a lot of repetition in Homer, although it takes a different form: Homer, famously, reuses epithets for characters, in part because it's a mnemonic aid.
Thanks for this, by the way, fun rabbit hole to go down! It made me reconsider some of my personal speculation about Genesis 1 - 2 (I had some interest in actually reading it as two distinct creation narratives arranged in sequence, but I think the parallelism in the rest of early Genesis makes it clearer they are the same event, being recapitulated.) I may need to pick up Alter's The Art of Biblical Narrative...
And the dates for the Gospels are in fact postulated to be very late (40 years at minimum, it's an ethernity)
The early critical scholars put them 100 years out or more, out of living memory of the depicted events! Which ties up my point nicely – my point is not that modern scholarship is saying "Christianity is true, you should believe it" but rather that it's very, very different from what was going on in the 1800s and early 1900s when the lore behind the current splits in modern American Protestantism was being written.
Even given the right circumstances I don't see the constellation of minor denominations finding another anchor point besides inerrancy.
Reformed denominations tend to believe in inerrancy but have never (in my experience) been particularly sold on YEC compared to [more] evangelical Christians, so if you don't see it, I would gently suggest that it's for want of looking :)
Glad that was helpful! I find this interesting to discuss.
The New Testament talks about the idea that the law of God is written on people's hearts absent even Scripture or the Holy Spirit.
I think this sort of bears out what we see throughout most of history. Even very cruel cultures often have at least some sense of moral reciprocity. But even the best cultures have a permission structure that allows one to harm others guilt-free.
And I would not say that is necessarily bad - or perhaps I would say that it is exactly that. It's probably good that we have a permission structure that allows us to defend ourselves. But historically a permission structure is what, it seems to me, permits abuse. People don't often say "theft is okay," "murder is fine," "rape is normal," they say "well Jews/blacks/Russians/etc. don't count." Fundamentally, what it boils down to, is often "s/he'd do the same to me." Which is why "bless your enemies" ended up being such a revolutionary moral idea.
Circling back to the (heh) genesis of this conversation, I think that "evolution" can (and historically has) become part of an abusive permission structure, thus the vehemence with which it is opposed (not only by YEC Christians, I seem to recall an article during peak woke about opposition from seculars for essentially the same reasons.)
I suspect it also doesn't help that a lot of confessional Protestantism is grounded in catechisms that were very literally written before modern Catholicism. Luther's small catechism was written before the Counter-Reformation was finished cooking; the Westminster Confession of Faith predates Vatican I, let along Vatican II. The Catholic church's stances today on things like "should we sell indulgences yes or no?" or "religious freedom, yes or no?" have changed dramatically since they were written. But the self-conception of both Protestants and Catholics sort of blinds them to seeing that in some ways Protestant churches are more (if I can use the phrase without seeing pejorative) stuck in their traditions than the Catholics.
A Modest Proposal is overdue for the Hollywood sequel treatment!
- Prev
- Next

Sure, and sometimes this sort of thing happens to people.
No, it's actually not. It's not even clear to you - you can only understand "7 billion" as a number; you can't really grasp the concept of 7 billion years.
Perhaps more to the point, my understanding is that there literally was not a word for billion available to the authors of Genesis. ANE cultures in general used very hyperbolic numbers in counting for rhetorical effect to mean "very large numbers," so if the Genesis text had said "the Earth is 7 billion years old" people at the time would likely have interpreted it symbolically: 7 being a sacred number in the ANE context, and "billion" (which would have been expressed as something like "myriads upon myriads upon myriads") being taken to mean "very old." If it had said that literally, I daresay you would be arguing that it was only ever intended as metaphor and since the people at the time would not have understood it as intended literally we shouldn't either and it's just a funny coincidence that it happened to be right.
And then in another 20 or 200 or 2,000 years, the age of the earth will be revised again and everyone would use it as evidence against the veracity of the text. (As a bit of an aside, the estimated age of the earth right now is 4 - 5 billion years, but obviously this also depends on when you start counting - so it's entirely coherent based on our current understanding to say the earth is, say, 13 billion years old, if you're talking about its constituent materials.)
Yep, there's a pretty consistent theme in Scripture of God's mercy being extended to the weak and powerless, and Scripture - by speaking through accessible ideas - is very accessible to non-sophisticated people. God's "tricks" are often played on the oppressive and wicked. There's a reason Christianity spread throughout the lower/slave class in Rome before it started hitting the literate elites.
I don't know where you get this idea of the "equality of souls" from, or what you mean by it, unless you're just talking about imago dei or the idea that everyone is equal in the eyes of God. There's no understanding in the OT or NT that everyone is equally good at everything.
You mean like...real life?
Why do you say this? It's not really a characteristic of successful religions (maybe Islam? But I think even Islam is very good at packaging up a narrative, and I think modern Islam is a bit dryer in terms of its interpretation than ancient Islam was.) True religion (c.f. James 1:27, Jeremiah 29:13) is relational as much or more than it is propositional.
Modern materialistic atheism - despite resembling nonfiction - is absolutely terrible as a religion. Very little ability to attract new converts, poor community formation, low rates of charitable giving, etc. Please don't take this as me endorsing a slightly different meme ("atheists aren't good people") - my point is that as far as we can tell taking dry scientific texts as the cornerstone of lifestyle and ethics is simply not appealing, nor is it a good way to perpetuate a culture. Traditional religions - which typically use literary techniques - have much better sticking power.
I also deny the premise that literature is not a way of conveying truth, or that literary methods cannot be used to convey literal truths - good historians use literary techniques left and right (as they should).
Are you arguing that God should not use natural memes that have high spreadability? Is the hyperliteral account you want from God a natural meme with high spreadability? If so, then (according to you) it counts against it's truth value. If it's not a natural meme with high spreadability, why would God use it?
Personally, I think it's actually remarkable how much credence archeological discoveries have lent to the Scriptural narrative. Just the slow shift on the timeline of the Gospels that we've been discussing is fascinating to me.
Sure, I agree God can and use other methods outside of the text. But I think it's pretty interesting how well the text of Scripture does use this.
More options
Context Copy link