@FtttG's banner p

FtttG

Gheobhaidh mé bás ar an gcnoc seo.

7 followers   follows 0 users  
joined 2022 September 13 13:37:36 UTC

https://firsttoilthenthegrave.substack.com/


				

User ID: 1175

FtttG

Gheobhaidh mé bás ar an gcnoc seo.

7 followers   follows 0 users   joined 2022 September 13 13:37:36 UTC

					
				

				

				

					

User ID: 1175

Yes, but not from the far East, hence unlikely to be hired by the CCP.

Lots of people want to be thought of as reliable. No one wants to be thought of as predictable.

Literally my favourite novel of all time. You're in for a treat. The film adaptation is also well worth checking out.

Over a hundred pages into The Camp of the Saints. It's readable enough once you get started, but so slow-paced that I don't exactly feel a compulsion to pick it up again after putting it down. At times it feels like an omnidirectional rant about everything Raspail hates about Western society.

Or alternatively, play video games that make you feel depressed and despairing (I was already doing this).

Not sure if I agree with the third point, which is equally true of basically every entertainment medium, few of which seem to inspire the same contempt.

As ever, the UK and the US are two countries separated by a common language, and the term "indie rock" refers to something very different depending on which side of the pond you're on. Per the American variant, Death Cab for Cutie's album Transatlanticism would probably be one of my desert island discs, and when listening to it there's not one track I ever feel the urge to skip, a rare feat indeed. It bears the unusual distinction where, if pressed, I'm pretty confident I could write out the lyrics to the entire album from memory without listening to any of the songs, a consequence of singer Ben Gibbard's unusually precise and clear diction.

In the UK and Ireland, the term is primarily associated with the legion of bands that mushroomed in the wake of Arctic Monkeys' initial chart success. I bought the Monkeys' first album the year it came out and listened to it a great deal, but don't really rate it anymore, nor any of their later material. Within a few years, some music critic had begun derisively referring to these hordes of interchangeable soundalike bands (Scouting for Girls, The Enemy among them) as "landfill indie". I was amused to learn a few months ago that the term is being applied to all those execrable insufferable post-punk bands like Fontaines DC, Sprints and Yard Act: "landfill post-punk".

The only indie rock album from the UK or Ireland I ever remember really enjoying was Bloc Party's debut Silent Alarm, which was actually released before Arctic Monkeys'. If you played a FIFA game between 2005-7 you probably heard either this song or this one (I think I first encountered the band when the latter song was used in a video game called Getting Up), but the whole album is well worth checking out.

It matters to ME.

I wish I was important enough to be the target of a honeypot attempt.

Some trans-identified males claim to be literally female (as in, a member of the female sex). Most acknowledge that they are of the male sex, but claim that they have a woman's "gender identity".

Even assuming this statement is true, it's entirely beside the point. Female sporting divisions are for people of the female sex, not for people who (claim to) have a female "gender identity".

Needless to say, any male person claiming to be female (in the sense of "the female sex") is not telling the truth. They may not be lying (that is, expressing a factual statement they know to be false), but the statement they are making is untrue. No male person is female, no male person can become female, sex is not a "spectrum".

That "trans women" are members of the male sex is kind of inherent in the definition of what a "trans woman". How would you propose to define a "trans woman" without reference to their male sex?

I don't think the left would go for that at all

Then why did voters in the state of Washington vote to ban male athletes from competing in female sporting events?

I certainly don't fear the spiders that are native to Ireland, but will admit that the idea of a tarantula walking across my skin gives me the willies. I watched Jumanji as a child and the only part that gave me nightmares was the black widows, yeesh.

Why is it that nobody pretends to be mentally retarded so that they can participate in the Special Olympics?

Good for a laugh.

why is it always spiders that are the swarmy bad guys in games?

I imagine arachnophobia is the most common animal phobia in the world, if not the most common phobia of any kind.

As has often been noted before, there aren't two leagues called "male" and "female". There is "female" and "open".

No need for “vagina inspection day” or however the hell Washington was planning to do it.

Cheek swab. Non-invasive. No one who wants males out of female sports is only doing so as a pretext to sexually assault minors.

And if you ban trans girls from the girls team, then where are they supposed to play?

The males' team. Being as they are male.

My favourite take on the alleged Jensen Huang honeypot operation so far:

I met my wife at a Popeye’s in Skokie, Illinois. I was in Skokie doing standup, she was in Skokie for reasons that she’s never explained. She walked up to me, and — in heavily-accented, broken English — said “You Jeff Mau? I blow you. I blow you now — hurry, let’s go!”

That’s not the type of thing that normally happens to me. I’m no troll, but it’s not like I commonly get unsolicited offers of oral sex. And while this woman — my future wife, Jane Baseball — was what rural folk might call “barn fodder”, it still seemed strange. But she was insistent: “Let’s go! Blow time!” she wailed. “Blow time now, get you things! Hurry!” I honestly went with her mostly to get her to stop yelling about blow jobs in public.

After receiving what can only be described as a “surly” blow job next to the dumpster behind a Popeye’s, my future wife yelled “Okay — the end! You marry me now!” When I expressed shock, she only yelled louder: “I BLOW YOU, NOW WE MARRY! LET’S GO, GET YOU THINGS!” When I tried to explain that that’s not how it works in America, she shrieked “I AMERICA! I AMERICA, BORN HERE! FLEENT CEE-TEE, MEE-SHEE-GAN!” I considered pointing out that people from Flint don’t call it “Flint City”, but I was also kind of afraid of seeming racist.

Big one for the Greek towel boys, huh.

I read The True Believer earlier this year, incredibly insightful.

Ireland recognized their sovereignty and banned settler imports. Isn’t this a meaningful gain?

Is it? Has an independent Palestinian state come one millimetre closer as a result of either development? Will Ireland banning settle imports have even the most meagre impact on Israel's GDP?

That's so funny, earlier this week I was thinking of this one YouTube video: https://youtu.be/6Qt3WW5VdKs

It is. But it's also the Tony Hawk meme.

Well, of course I know him. He's me.

If you are pro-Palestinian, you don't want either of those two outcomes, but it's not like you have more direct actions available than those that shift Israel's own cost-benefit calculus. The most obvious way to reorder their preferences is to make their preferred options worse by imposing external costs; since they are hardly Juche Korea and therefore significantly depend on foreign trade and military aid, turning international institutions and public sentiment against them is actually an effective measure.

This reasoning makes sense to me. Where the pro-Palestine movement loses me is that I can't envision any plausible pathway by which the above goals could be accomplished by any of the following:

  • hurling cartons of milk at Joe Biden
  • trying to ruin Ed Sheeran's career over his refusal to use the word "genocide"
  • boycotting Jewish-owned businesses in Philadelphia
  • burning down the Limoges city hall

and so on.

This is what I find so strange about the pro-Palestine movement. On the surface, their goals seem sensible and logical, and yet they're remarkably promiscuous about the tactics they use to accomplish these goals. The movement seems fundamentally allergic to discussions about costs and benefits, about message discipline, about effective coalition-building. Intent seems to be all that matters: as long as you wave a Palestinian flag and chant "from the river to the sea", anything goes. There's this staggeringly wide gulf between, on the one hand, the people talking about using targeted boycotts to put pressure on the Israeli economy, and on the other, deranged nutters engaged in orgies of impulsive violence and smashing up Jewish-owned businesses hundreds of miles from Israel. And maybe that's true of every sufficiently large political coalition, but what I find strange about the pro-Palestine movement is that the former group (the ostensibly reasonable moderates who are thinking in terms of long-term strategy) never condemn the latter group: the people calling for economic boycotts never say that the people smashing up Jewish businesses are doing a disservice to the cause.

And again, like you say, I'm vastly more sympathetic to the Israelis than the Palestinians, so if the pro-Palestine movement wants to keep shooting itself in the foot, maybe that's no big deal. (Although they can certainly do a lot of damage while shooting themselves in the foot. I felt pretty upset seeing photos of the burnt-out Limoges city hall.) But, like – aren't you more invested in actually accomplishing your goals? Do you think that throwing cartons of milk at Joe Biden is the best way to accomplish your goals? If so, you're entitled to believe that, I'm just – surprised. Perplexed, even.

I say deBoer is wrong about white/black relations: manipulating white people's attitudes towards black people clearly does work, or slavery would never have been ended.

But this is exactly what I was saying about instrumental vs. terminal goals. Manipulating white attitudes towards black people may have been a necessary precondition for the abolition of slavery, but no sensible person would pursue it as an end in itself. That is, if black Americans were offered the choice between a world in which a) chattel slavery was ended, but white American attitudes towards black Americans were unchanged; or b) white Americans felt no animosity towards black, but chattel slavery still existed as before – I imagine the overwhelming majority would pick the former.

And it need hardly be said that the abolition of slavery was a material win for the cause of racial equality, not a symbolic one.

In more concrete terms: if you accept that Israelis and Palestinians are primarily competing for the same limited resource (sovereignty over a strip of land) and so their utility is zero-sum, and believe that "purely symbolic" acts and attitude shifts for the Palestinian side do nothing, then why do they bother you so much? If meals > UN condemnations, then shouldn't a pro-Israeli be happy that pro-Palestinians waste their time on UN condemnations instead of providing them with meals (or all-expenses-paid drone pilot internships in Ukraine)?

What I would really like to see is a durable peace between Israelis and Palestinians, perhaps in the form of a two-state solution, albeit not necessarily. No more rocket attacks, no more suicide bombings, no more "mowing the grass". I think idiotic stunts like this reduce (however slightly) the likelihood of that coming to pass, as they make the pro-Palestine movement seem like a gang of petulant thugs who won't listen to reason and who will pursue blatantly self-destructive courses of action for no tangible end.

"Purely symbolic" nonviolent gestures like formal "recognition" of the state of Palestine or UN declarations don't bother me, except in so far as they amount to a maintenance of the uneasy status quo which has existed for decades. They don't bring a durable peace between the two peoples a millimetre closer. They seem like a tremendous waste of time and effort which could be better spent elsewhere.