Eunuchs were not created to make un-honeypottable officials, they were created because the emperors had large harems and did not want to get cucked.
It’s important to keep in mind that everything we know about these periods was written by the political rivals of the eunuchs. Don’t fall for the Confucian officials propaganda that eunuchs always lead to corrupt rule. It’s true that they often did when child emperors were on the throne, but with powerful adult emperors, they were often effective and loyal officials. The emperors kept using them for a reason. They knew history and knew that eunuchs had a failure mode, but kept choosing to use them. It’s not like they tried them in the Han dynasty and then were like “whoops, that went poorly, let’s never do that again.” The Qing still had eunuchs 2000 years later.
If the Republicans start calling for his impeachment the dems will have to join in.
Doesn’t zoning control where strip clubs can set up shop almost everywhere? What’s the reason that this same principle couldn’t be applied to drag shows?
How come you’re posting under a pseudonym and not your real name? This forum would not exist if all social medial had to be tied to real human users.
If you are going to retaliate, you want to pretend to do it for some other reason but wink enough that everyone, especially Google and OpenAI know it’s a retaliation. Former officials actually seem perfect for this. Current leadership should keep their traps shut though.
That doesn’t seem particularly relevant. It’s never possible to prove murder with 100% certainty, especially if you are admitting absurd mental states that are totally out of character for the murder. You could say the same thing about sudden hallucinations making murder with a gun actually manslaughter.
That’s not how thought experiments work. You can’t resolve the trolly problem by just saying, “well what if there is a third track with no one on it! Ha!”
None of those situational tweaks apply in the scenario I proposed. The watcher can trivially save the dangler. They are not afraid of heights, and they are plenty strong enough. It costs them basically nothing to save the dangler. If you want to argue that there is still some risk, we can even make them tied into an anchor point by a climbing harness so it’s completely safe. To me that’s murder.
The burns example where your buddy is in horrible pain and bound to die soon is another one that works. You can play with it by having him be actively begging for death or just screaming wordlessly.
It’s also not clear to me that action vs inaction is a super bright line. I would certainly consider someone a murderer who stared down passively as someone else slowly lost their grip on the top of a cliff when the watcher could have reached down to save them at any point.
There is excess demand for adoptable infants (though I doubt there is for downy ones).
The difference between fetuses and adults is not that fetuses have lives less worth living, it is that they are very different looking organisms and it’s not at all obvious to people that don’t believe in souls being delivered at the moment that the sperm burrows into the egg that fetuses are people. That’s the thing you need to engage with. Some people might be arguing that it is permissible to “put people out of their misery” if they have lives which don’t seem worth living, but this is a much more fringe position than people who just think fetuses are not people.
When two bull moose square off, they’re just locking horns for the fun of it and have no eye towards the female moose off to the side right? They grow those horns for pure intersex competition.
Well maybe the spaceships don’t represent an advanced vehicle for them. There is no objective point on the tech continuum at which a vehicle becomes advanced.
Not monkeys who found spaceships, just members of a larger society who are less advanced than the ones who supplied their tools, like we see with different human communities all the time.
I was using implies in the sense of logical implication, which does mean the same thing as requires.
It’s quite possible for operators of technology to be much less competent / impressive than the people who built that technology. In fact, that seems to be the typical pattern. Perhaps our aliens are the equivalent of a bunch of yahoos driving around Toyota technicals in the Sahel. The fact that their trucks have advanced microchips in them does not mean they are capable of building such microchips. When you consider the possibility of deep time where civilizations exist on the scale of hundreds of thousands or millions of years this seems even more possible.
I do agree with you that aliens seem pretty unlikely, I’m just pushing back on the idea that advanced technology implies advanced other things.
Nails are the best example of female fashion that really isn’t for the male gaze. Women love to say they are wearing miniskirts for themselves or whatever, and it always makes me roll my eyes, but when they say that about vile half inch claws I believe them. Idk maybe some men like it, but I don’t think it’s many.
If you read the captive mind, it talks about how the Soviets used exactly the kind of wokescolding behaviors we are all so familiar with to bring the Polish literary establishment to heel. The government wokescolds were called “dialectitions” and they would lead discussion assuming the role of a facilitator in exactly the same pose anyone who has done a DEI training would instantly recognize only with slightly more iron behind the velvet glove.
A renewables only grid is obviously possible, it just involves using a lot of batteries to create synthetic inertia and last through the night, which is just power engineering. It’s not some magic future technology, it’s just a question of execution. There are tons of privately funded solar projects just waiting for utility hookup. Also, there are renewables without the base load problem. Hydro is the biggest one in use right now, but next gen geothermal seems pretty promising (thanks Texas!), and as you pointed out nuclear is great though technically not renewable.
I do agree that Germany did some very silly stuff, and you shouldn't prematurely kill fossil fuels, but we are getting to a point where solar can compete on its own merits and at that point we should let it win.
Maybe “upper middle class” isn’t the right term for them, especially at the higher end, but the fact remains that anyone whose wealth is primarily drawn from their own labor is just not in the same category as people who derive their wealth from owning. There are a few exceptions like CEOs who manage established companies rather than founding, but for the most part the people paying the very high income taxes are not the super wealthy. When the super wealthy do pay high income taxes, it’s generally pretty trivial compared with the main bulk of their wealth. If you don’t want to call top earners who can save low double digit millions “upper middle class,” that’s fine, but it is import to distinguish them from billionaires and centimillionares.
High income != high wealth. High income people are for the most part the upper middle class. They are the loyal retainers of the true ownership class. The truely rich don’t pay much in taxes.
That’s why they were proposing a legal framework where it becomes profitable for the restaurant to go after rude customers. If the restaurant gets most of the fine and there is an additional even more punitive fine for reviewing a restaurant after you’ve been found against (and running an anon review service is banned), you could reset the incentives. I would be mostly fine with all of this except for the banning of anon review sites because I don’t like the idea of ID gating the internet, even a small part of it.
Buying power mostly yes, quality of life obviously not.
Do you seriously think the quality of life for a lower class American is the same in Mexico as it would be for a lower class Mexican who grew up there, speaks the language, has a large extended family there, and associates it with all the nostalgic qualities which make one’s homeland appealing?
One of your main bits of evidence that Americans are disrespectful is that we dress like slobs, but that's not what respect means. You can tell a little story about how dressing up conveys respect for the people around you by showing that you put in effort, and respect for yourself by presenting yourself nicely, but you can also tell a story about how dressing down conveys respect for the people around you by releasing them from the obligation to perform a silly social ritual that per everyone's revealed preferences they don't want to perform, and respect for yourself by living authentically. Another one would be that dressing nicely shows off either wealth or a particular kind of cultural competency that encodes class in a way that is inaccessible to some people, therefore putting them down and displaying contempt for anyone who can't manage it. Since you have some background in fashion, this might be an alien perspective to you, but it's definitely not the case that nicer-clothes = more respect. Respect is about how you treat people. How you dress is part of it, and showing up to a wedding in sweats is obviously disrespectful, but it's not at all obvious that going about your daily life in casual clothing is disrespectful.
I'll allow that we may have had a hiatus in class expression between the 40s and 70s (though I'm pretty dubious even of this), but the idea that class was invented in the 80s is absurd. The robber barons, Southern planters, and the Easter financiers around the turn of the 20th century were all way more overt in their class expression than the elite of the 80s. We had a rash of anarchist terrorism motivated on a class basis that resulted in a president getting assassinated. Just walk through the historic part of Detroit and tell me with a straight face that class was invented in America in the 80s.
Finally, the idea that Europeans should be held up as exemplars of respect is crazy to anyone who has worked in a multinational company. Southern Europeans are generally perfectly lovely, but nearly without fail upon having some distant co-worker be rude and unprofessional to me I'll look up where they are based and it's somewhere in Northern Europe (and no they aren't anglophone). I don't actually mind this too much because it means they don't dissemble and you know where you stand with them. I'd much rather work with a Dutchman or German than someone from a high power distance culture who will either not call out a bad idea if they are lower rank or bully people if they are higher rank. Fortunately, there is a culture that manages to both be low power distance and professional: mine. Yes, I understand that this is culturally dependent and everyone has their own perspective. My perspective is that Americans do by far the best job of both remembering that their co-workers are people with egos and getting shit done. (I will say that the French that I've worked with in a professional context seem much closer to the American norms of professionalism than a lot of other Europeans).
For what it’s worth I think one of your two options is the most likely explanation, but this is a false dilemma. There is a third option: non-cis people might be more likely to lie (both to themselves and others) to make themselves seem more interesting.
- Prev
- Next

You can tell this isn't true by the way intact officials and generals held most of the power through most of Chinese and greater Sinosphere history. The eunuchs were officials of the inner court aka the Emperor's personal household. Other men were not allowed to be part of the inner court on account of the thousands of concubines. In a well-ordered traditional Chinese court, eunuch officials barely held any power. Most of their power came from the fact that they served as the personal messengers of the Emperor, and they generally only leveraged this into significant power when there were weak child emperors. There were a few periods where they were given actual official roles by strong emperors (it was fashionable in very early Chinese history and cropped up a few other times), but this was generally quite rare.
An intact official growing powerful and taking over the government with his own personal clan just wasn't something that actually happened very often. Dynasties were conquered from the outside (Ming -> Qing, Song -> Jin / Song -> Yuan), overthrown by internal revolts (Yuan -> Ming), disintegrated into warring states (Han, Tang) or got skinwalkered by maternal clans taking over (Western Han, Tran dynasty in Vietnam). This last category somewhat looks like the internal clan takeover scenario you're talking about, but the key vector of power was the palace women and Empress Dowagers in particular, not intact exam-system officials. I'm sure you could find some examples in minor dynasties or kingdoms that never managed to unify China during an interregnum just because there are so many of them, but this wasn't a common failure mode, so it wasn't something that Chinese statesmen, who knew their own history very well, were all that worried about.
More options
Context Copy link