phosphorus2
No bio...
User ID: 3264
Not really. Everyone knows transwomen aren't really women; if they were, there would be nothing to discuss.
Now that's just not true. You can't just say "everyone secretly agrees with me, including the people whose words and actions indicate disagreement" so easily.
You do the exact same thing though, here it is:
Because how sports are set up right now is inherently unfair, everyone knows it and no one seems to care about this issue except in the one limited circumstance of trans athletes.
Your entire argument is centered around fairness, but you never really establish what you consider to be fair.
Maybe they change their mind, maybe they don't. But if they are going to push the whole gender project then they need to own the whole project. If they want to use gender to demand that women be 50% of STEM or whatever then they shouldn't be allowed to escape the implications of that same argument when it is applied to sports. I'm not going to fight for them to have their cake and eat it too for no real benefit to myself besides upholding an idea of fairness.
Ok but that is not that hard for me to swallow. Like I'd rather have this wedge issue on the table every election for the next 20 years, it makes people I don't like fight each other and it undermines their shared intellectual tradition that I also don't like. I would rather hit them over the head with this, I at least get something out of that, I will trade that for something was not my project in the first place.
Not to advocate for this as a form of accelerationism, I don't realistically see trans in women's sports long term. But because this is an easy issue to run on, and if it gets settled then you can't run on it anymore, so keep it festering for as long as possible.
Well, the other tribe is the one dominating the culture war. It's ok if you just want to surrender to them, but you should realize what you're doing.
I am saying that if there is a culture war then this issue is a battle. And I see my side as having (relatively) no stakes in who wins this battle, and fighting it doesn't seem very strategic, and not fighting it means that my outgroup fights it amongst themselves. This is not a Fulda Gap battle where if its lost then the commies have free reign on Europe. This would be paradropping a bunch of marines onto Hill 875, some random hill with no strategic value, that the NVA and VC are themselves for some reason fighting over. Why not let them fight? You don't win a war by fighting for Hill 875s, you win it by fighting for Fulda Gaps.
At a stroke, this instantly solves the transgender issue.
Women's sports is something that was foisted upon me. Its not that I disagree with it, I do mostly agree with it and think its a good thing, but I don't really care. Its not my issue. And it became an issue and law because of an intellectual movement (60s/70s feminism) that I wouldn't say is fundamentally flawed, they had a lot of valid points, but I think it overall has a lot of issues.
Everything trans has also been foisted upon me. I think its silly and not true. It came out of the intellectual movement that also gave us women's sports, (60s/70s feminism) and it came out of the parts of that movement that I find the most wrong and disagreeable.
So now to take stock of the sports issue - women's sports is a thing because of the other tribe, and they care about it way more than me. Same with trans. But trans is only a thing because of all of the pathologies of the movement that gave us women's sports. Like you can't have the trans we have today without the intellectual foundation of 60s feminism, the concepts of gender and ideas of social construction etc. that I think are wrong.
What I don't get is if you are like me and agree with the above, why would we not vote for trans in women's sports? Its not something I really care much about in the first place, and its totally enabled by the wrong and harmful views of the other tribe. They either need to repudiate their wrong and harmful views or they need to own it and have their pet project destroyed. You can't just nuke all shared institutions with your stupid gender views except for the exclusively women ones where it only affects stuff you care about, no make them get down in the muck with everyone else and deal with the consequences.
You're telling me to concede to the other side what they will not concede to me and I'm not going to do it and its not reasonable and for you to ask.
Ok you can contend that, and think what you think, and have the position we should do XY & Z. But I don't agree with you, I want something else. That leaves us at an impasse, because what is going to happen? We can kick him out or keep him, we can't do both.
We solved this problem by collectively agreeing to elect representatives who then write the laws that decide what happens. But it only works if people do what they agreed to do, and trust that the other side will do the same. Consequentially you taking the position that you can do what you think is fair instead of what the law says breaks the system, we are back to our original problem, and now its really hard to solve because your side cannot be trusted to do what they agreed to do.
To argue that "It's the law!" is not the final say is to argue against the rule of law itself. Are you going to do that, argue against the rule of law? No? Then what else is there to say? Either come out and argue against the rule of law explicitly or concede that the law should be followed. But don't sit here and ask for unprincipled exceptions, why would I care?
You are conflating fairness with harm. If I switch out all of my pawns with queens in our chess game have I harmed you? Is the game fair?
Its unfair to me, as I directly stated, and I have given my reasons as to why. You are asking me to yield to your opinion on fairness, while ignoring and adding qualifiers to what I consider unfair. Why would I do that?
No one woke up one day and decided to not enforce the law. The law just slowly stopped being enforced over the years, or was never enforced in the first place. As far as I know, this was the case even under W and maybe even previous Republican presidents.
This is not fair. That it happened over years does not make it fair.
Suddenly deciding to start enforcing it after it hadn't been enforced for a long time is a major policy change, and, yes, it is unfair.
You get to be unfair to me but I don't get to be unfair to you. Nice.
because it's in the definition: fascism is nosiness, interfering with the citizen's private lives, even the most intimate. Fascists at best don't care about others' intimacy, at worst they have a control fetish. Why should anyone care about what degenerates do, consensually, apart from them?
I hate when people just make stuff up like this, no I'm sorry but that is not what fascism is. You clearly just made that up on the spot and put zero thought into it which is lazy and rude. Like the communists were notoriously nosy, nosier than the fascists, does that make them fascists? Things can be bad without also being fascist.
When did the US left promise to enforce immigration law?
That is just the standard assumption for dealing with societies. People are subject to the law, and a law isn't a law if it is not enforced.
What exactly are you trying to argue here?
That if a political faction doesn't explicitly promise to enforce some law it shouldn't have to?
That if a political faction doesn't like the law they can just not enforce the law instead of changing it?
That it is ok to not enforce laws that you don't like?
The law isn't unfair; what is unfair is suddenly starting to enforce the law after it's been unenforced for decades and people have built their lives around the expectation that it won't be enforced. Enforcing it for new arrivals is entirely fair.
We have a process to decide what is and is not fair. We elect representatives, representatives write and pass laws, and then we all agree to be bound by the laws. Do you not agree?
Then why is it fair for your side, the pro immigration side, to just not enforce the law? Why does your side get to selectively enforce the rules? Why do you get to make claims as to what is and isn't fair when you have already ignored what we agreed on?
I think what the US needs is a grand bargain between the two sides on immigration: one big amnesty for those already there, obviously excluding criminals, etc., and to then start actually enforcing the law.
I give you: everything you want on the issue
You give me: you promise to follow the law, which you have already promised to do, and which already gives me everything I want on the issue
Wow great, what a deal, sign me up
I do feel it is unfair that people who've lived in the US for years or decades under the understanding that the law will not be enforced have had the rug pulled out from under them. No, you can't just say "but it's the law!". Imagine a teenager smokes some weed on the understanding that the prohibition is not enforced, and then a tough-on-crime district attorney starts enforcing it and suddenly he's spending a year in jail (the maximum sentence) and will never be able to get a good job. People act differently based on how and whether laws are enforced, and suddenly changing that retroactively is unfair.
Oh look, one paragraph later the I am being told that you are just going to ignore the law if you think its unfair.
No, I DON'T think you're antisemitic because your post reads as a person who is pretending to be an antisemite who is in turn pretending to not be an antisemite and just doing criticism, and that's the problem.
When you crank it up to 110% for the entire post it doesn't make it better. You need to have something plausible to engage with and then a FEW firecrackers thrown in there. When you pour it on it is just way too obvious. Like it doesn't even seem like you're authentically antisemitic, go for a masterpiece paragraph inside something solid, not an entire masterpiece post.
The Dem agenda is gibs. Everyone loves gibs.
Arguably, the Democrats spent the
You don't like the democrats, ok. But what you describe is not unique to democrats. Voting to give yourself free stuff is the bane of all democracies in existence, since forever. It is the quintessential "populists run amok" agenda item, not just a "gibs" thing.
Do you not see this same impulse in Donald? If so, why bash the dems then? If not, how? He is I think the most shameless of all of them. Interesting that he killed the Romney / Ryan wing of the GOP that was the only real force pushing against entitlement growth.
he has visibly kept most of the promises he made in the campaign (with a minor problem of the Iran war).
Trump campaigned on ending forever wars and he campaigned on lowering gas prices / inflation. Those were heavily featured. Now he's got a war that he started and which looks like he can't finish, and its raising gas prices a lot and causing inflation. That seems like a major problem, not a minor one? And a very visible problem?
He has kept promises on immigration for example, but the nature of that problem is that when there isn't a crisis it doesn't get much attention. Yeah he solved the problem, he kept that promise, but doing that also makes the problem a lot less visible. Compare to the Iran war - very visible, lot of air time. And its causing gas and diesel to shoot up, which is also very visible.
Secondly, the Democrats have no serious agenda. They don’t have an economic agenda, a foreign policy agenda, a social agenda, their entire political agenda seems to be “Prevent Trump from doing things, and hate on Israel.”
Do they need an agenda to win an election? Does it help them?
First thing is that agendas don't have to be serious or even good, they just have to be popular. “Prevent Trump from doing things" seems like it would be a pretty popular agenda, as he is -20 net approval.
Second thing is that agendas should also not be unpopular. When Dems do have an actual agenda it is very often very unpopular. Can't be hit over the head with the wrong side of a 80:20 wedge issue if you haven't taken a side!
Third is that by having no set national agenda Dems don't get pegged to a national agenda in purple state races, red state Dems can more credibly run as centrists when they aren't tied down to Kamala.
So I don't think having an agenda helps them. It's probably the best thing they could do to be honest.
That's because of the precedent set by European police officers. They don't have a reputation for suicide-by-cop. They don't have a reputation for turning off body-cams at suspicious times. They don't have a reputation for shady protection schemes for rotten-apple police-officers. If American police want the right to stop random strangers, they must establish accountability and through it, build public trust.
This doesn't make any sense. Sometimes, rarely, crazy people in the US attack the police and force the police to shoot them, therefore the police need to build enough trust with the public to do basic policing work?
American police already have the right to stop random strangers. What they can and cannot do is defined by the law. It has nothing to do with public trust or accountability or context. This is also the reason why those people could be stopped in Germany or the UK - because the laws are different. Not because the public trusts the police more.
Biden didn't really ignore the law on immigration. One could make the argument (which I would agree with) that he ignored the spirit of what the law intended, but his parole abuse followed the letter since every applicant technically received an individual decision, and the DHS asserted individualized "significant public benefit" findings. The definitions of those things were so wishy washy that it could mean almost anything.
I would consider "pretending words mean what we want them to mean instead of what they actually mean so we can technically follow the law" the same as just ignoring the law.
Immigration law is a trainwreck in general, so there are tons. One particularly noteworthy issue that Biden abused was the parole authority. This is something the 2024 bill would have ameliorated somewhat. Then Trump cynically torpedoed that bill with MAGA promising he'd deliver a much stronger bill if he became President. Then he did almost nothing statutorily.
It is a trainwreck because one side just ignores the law. Look at your example of Biden's parole abuse. The law says that the pres admin can temporarily parole individuals into the US on a case by case basis. Biden admin parole in millions of him over his term, this was done categorically, not at all case by case.
Why rely on another law to fix parole? The original law is already clear and is ignored. Trump was able to shut down the border with the laws on the books, what is another law that gives concession to the pro side going to do?
Maybe you should try to consider why those muslims hate you, and no, scantily clad blondes munching on burgers and freedom fries is not the reason.
e.g.:
The second thing we call you to, is to stop your oppression, lies, immorality and debauchery that has spread among you.
(a) We call you to be a people of manners, principles, honour, and purity; to reject the immoral acts of fornication, homosexuality, intoxicants, gambling's, and trading with interest.
We call you to all of this that you may be freed from that which you have become caught up in; that you may be freed from the deceptive lies that you are a great nation, that your leaders spread amongst you to conceal from you the despicable state to which you have reached.
...
You are the nation who, rather than ruling by the Shariah of Allah in its Constitution and Laws, choose to invent your own laws as you will and desire. You separate religion from your policies, contradicting the pure nature which affirms Absolute Authority to the Lord and your Creator. You flee from the embarrassing question posed to you: How is it possible for Allah the Almighty to create His creation, grant them power over all the creatures and land, grant them all the amenities of life, and then deny them that which they are most in need of: knowledge of the laws which govern their lives?
...
You are a nation that exploits women like consumer products or advertising tools calling upon customers to purchase them. You use women to serve passengers, visitors, and strangers to increase your profit margins. You then rant that you support the liberation of women.
Do you have any evidence that this was the ayatollah's personal policy, as opposed to a broader regime policy?
Per Article 110 of Iran's Constitution, the ayatollah's personal policy IS the regime policy.
What’s your evidence he wasn’t acting in their national self-interest?
I actually got Khamenei and Khomeini mixed up, but I don't think it changes much as they were both islamic fundamtalists who did stupid things.
Going back to Khomeini, the hostage crisis. Which Khamenei strongly supported. What did they get kidnapping a bunch of diplomats? They got to feel great sticking it to the great satan? What did they lose? They pissed off a superpower who then donated a bunch of military equipment to Iraq, a country that invaded them like a year after Iran pissed off its old superpower ally. To quote la wik:
If Iran had wanted to just throw of the American yoke and not been so annoying about they'd be in much better shape. Look at the Vietnamese - they kicked the US out, they did it without Ho Chi Minh yelling "death to America" for 50 years, and today in 2026 the US and Vietnam get along just fine, we're even somewhat friendly. But of course Iran can't help themselves, paramount is defeating the great satan. This is the general theme - they just can't help themselves.
Another example - the Fatwa against Salman Rushdie. What does Iran get from this? I can't think of anything but to satisfy some internal muslim purity demand. What did they lose? A decade of sour relations with the UK and Europe. And they made him famous, and he sold a ton of books.
More recently - some girl doesn't wear her hijab right so they kill her. What does Iran gain from this? International condemnation, international sanctions, half a year of internal protests where they shoot hundreds more. Shocking that Iran's most educated and (what would be) their most productive citizens don't want to live in that envornment. Shocking their elite human capital doesn't want to live in an islamic theocracy. Really serves the national interest to scare those people off, but hey - at least allah is happy.
Honestly there are like a million things like this of Iran being stupid because they're led by islamic fundamentalists. Is it in Iran's interest to keep picking fights with Israel? What exactly is the root of that conflict, Iran's security needs? Or because they don't like da Joos? How exactly is their nuclear weapons program going? They endure decades of economic isolation, for what? Where are the nukes? Did they stick it to the great satan with the nukes, or did they get no nukes and get bombed? There are ways to defend yourself without making yourself an international pariah, but they can't help but fund every terrorist org in existence. Like oh my god, shocking they get regularly bombed.
Ok to engage in realpolitik / geostrategic logic the first assumption is that states are rational actors acting in their own self interest. I dont think khomeni was a rational actor, he was an islamic fundamtalist. I think the junta giving direction to the clerics would be a much better situation, if that is actually the case.
No, I think killing muslims who hate me is a good thing in and of itself. But tbh if I were president I dont think I'd have started this war and I dont think as it stands the benefits have been worth the costs.
- Prev
- Next

I want to sort out a disconnect you are making, you are making a conflation. This is your original claim:
"Because how sports are set up right now is inherently unfair, everyone knows it and no one seems to care about this issue except in the one limited circumstance of trans athletes. But trans athletes are not an actual issue, they mathematically can not be."
Your claim as to what as to what everyone knows was not that "Height is an advantage in basketball", it was that basketball (and sports when generalized) is inherently unfair BECAUSE height is an ADVANTAGE in basketball, which therefore CAUSES basketball to be unfair. You need to establish that this causes basketball to be unfair, otherwise you are conflating inherent advantage with fairness.
You do not establish this connection, and all evidence points to people not agreeing with you. They watch and play basketball as is, height advantage and all. They do not complain it is unfair, they do not see it as an issue to be addressed. So yes, what you are doing is exactly the same. You are claiming everyone secretly agrees with what you think makes a game unfair, and their words and actions clearly indicate that they do not secretly agree with you. They indicate that they do not agree with you.
But in a lot of ways this is not really the point you are making and somewhat tangential, like ok you commit the same rhetorical sins as you point out in others, so what, that's not the meat of the argument. What is being pointed out is that "differences we aren't really fully in control of like height aren't considered an unfair advantage in basketball, so why is MtF trans an issue? It was never a level playing field anyways". You make this argument here and here:
A lot that can be said, I do agree with you that the advantage of mtf is broadly similar to the advantage of height, and that if we applied the same reasoning to both we would arrive at the same outcome. But I think my problem with you is how you arrive there rhetorically, you are taking the idea of fairness put forth by the anti-MtF in women's sports side and pointing out the double standard - they don't say the same thing about height which is also an advantage.
But that idea of fairness is not the actual idea of what a "fair" sport is, and is not a good one because there is no way it for any sport to ever be fair under that definition. Sports are inherently physical contests, games with rules. If they are inherently unfair because of inherent physical advantage then who would want to play an unfair game? Who would recognize the winner of an unfair process as the actual best, the actual winner? What could possibly be a fair sport under this definition, flipping a coin?
The real definition of fairness in sport is that if all parties agree on the rules beforehand and the rules are followed throughout then it is fair. The only way a sport could possibly be unfair is if the rules were not followed. I agree this is really just a proxy fight, but the entire line of argument misunderstands what a sport or even a game is and what makes one fair. And I don't see how you can simultaneously justify having a separate MtF included in women's sports and NOT not justifying bio women getting their own league, seems to defeat the purpose.
More options
Context Copy link