@VoxelVexillologist's banner p

VoxelVexillologist

๐Ÿ‡บ๐Ÿ‡ธ Multidimensional Radical Centrist

1 follower   follows 0 users  
joined 2022 September 04 18:24:54 UTC

				

User ID: 64

VoxelVexillologist

๐Ÿ‡บ๐Ÿ‡ธ Multidimensional Radical Centrist

1 follower   follows 0 users   joined 2022 September 04 18:24:54 UTC

					

No bio...


					

User ID: 64

This is what I get for reading too quickly. Yes, it should have been clear.

Without wholly endorsing it, I could see a fourth: that the people in the past understood and documented it imperfectly, but in a way accessible to them. Trying to explain the scale of The Big Bang, life coming into being, and billions of years of evolution by natural selection seems like something the contemporaries of the Epic of Gilgamesh would describe in words like Genesis 1.

mainstream Christianity (excluding your Unitarians and so forth) absolutely needs the miracles of Jesus.

Does it really? The miracles are impressive, for sure, but the moral weight of Christianity falls pretty heavily upon the cross, which I don't think is typically considered one of the canonical miracles.

Christianity without loaves and fishes, raising Lazarus, or walking on water IMO stands, if maybe a bit weaker.

This was effectively a Sunday School class physically at a church. Although I suppose not a "service" per se.

Or Christ's statement regarding His body and blood, which most Protestants - particularly Evangelical Protestants who are likely to be YECers - agree is metaphorical?

You're excluding Catholics and a few mainline Protestants from "pretty much everyone" here. Literal wars have been fought over this.

But from what I know, you're correct about the Evangelical point of view.

as a trojan horse for treating the literal words of Jesus as a metaphor

Heh, I once had to sit through a talk by a woman from Answers in Genesis, during which this exact point was raised about doubting Seven Literal Days leading to doubting the rest of the book. A female friend who was there later said it was funny, because Paul has some apparently-literal lines about letting women in the church speak, and the woman speaking didn't feel the need to comment on those specifically.

I wasn't suggesting "advanced ancient civilization" specifically, but that the contemporaries of, say, Stonehenge might have disappeared without much trace. Doggerland, for example, has been known about for a while.

like what you'd see from a global flood

I feel like I saw a NYT headline recently lamenting that truly ancient archaeology sites would largely be on ancient coastlines. With the changes since the last ice age, most of those would then be underwater and either completely gone or incredibly difficult to explore.

But "creation science" is such a grab bag I'm really not sure if that's relevant given some of the dates in question being older than "Young Earth".

I have found myself becoming a compulsive purveyor of Old Things as of late. Old architecture, old artworks, old customs.

I was wondering the other day if there were space in the modern culture for a Western equivalent of Mishima. Although I don't know how impactful a novel could be in this day in age, or exactly what notion of "lost Western culture" it would be a requiem for.

Finished As I Lay Dying. I remember hating the stream-of-consciousness writing style as a kid, but I thought it was easier for me now as an adult. The self-inflicted comedy of errors was sad, if relatable, and foretold from quite early on. Might read more Faulkner in the future.

Picked up There Is No Antimemetics Division next. I believe I've seen it recommended here before.

disciplines where women have a legitimate advantage, like gymnastics

Women's gymnastics is fundamentally different from men's gymnastics: they do different events with only a bit of overlap. It's not hard to find videos of athletes joking around trying each other's events, but women aren't going to manage rings any time soon, and I have no clue how the men would do on the beam.

Equestrian is the only individual event where men and women compete against each other, but there are also a few mixed team events (relays, typically) in other sports.

Lightweight rowing seems to be going away (no longer an Olympic event), but is an example of a team weight class sport.

Why are they still hiring, even?

Heh, it's absolutely conspiracy-brained, but if you consider the accumulated network traffic they might have, they could easily have a training corpus (of private communications!) that dwarfs the frontier labs.

I don't think it's really explored in the series, but the difference between Data, a self-aware android and character, and the ship's computer, which seems on par with Claude (or so) feels particularly salient. Maybe at the time it was a convenient tool for the writers, but I'm not sure how I'd describe it even. For lack of a better term, Data is shown to have a soul, but the computer does not. All sides seem to have lots of strong opinions on which our current models more strongly resemble.

Vulnโ€™s arenโ€™t just about finding novel ways to make your app crash. Turning a bug into a working exploit is difficult.

This is funny to me because on the other side of the fence (development), a segfault is by default a very-high-priority bug on the basis that they are potential security issues.

Unless of course you want to define these activities so as to require a human element.

I'm not convinced the human element definition is wrong, even if I wouldn't fully endorse it today either.

Without a human-derived training corpus, what is any of us capable of?

Demonstrably, together we got to where we are now. It'd be interesting to see how well AI could start from scratch.

There are at least theoretical limits to resolution as a function of aperture and distance: spy planes could conceivably focus better by being closer.

Even if there is something humans can do which AI fundamentally cannot do (doubtful)

All the subjective things? Enjoy a beautiful sunrise? Love another as a spouse? Raise a child? Be a friend? Believe in God? Meaningful, not just aesthetic art?

Beyond that, all existent AI I'm aware of was trained on existing human knowledge. Without a human-derived training corpus, what is it capable of?

Not saying those could never happen, but it's not obvious to me that they could.

preclude the possibility of AI.

I think it's reasonable to point to those as bounds on "intelligence" (which is itself poorly defined): if your super intelligence model is effectively "omniscient", that part is provably not possible. What is possible seems a bit unclear, but I won't be surprised if it's "less than Skynet" even if it still changes nearly everything.

Even if frontier AI the spreadsheet on PCs stopped all today, we could replace nearly all accountants and financial planners with the technology we currently have.

This statement was largely true in the 1980s, but there are more accountants today than there were then. They aren't driving calculators anymore, and the tax code has grown rapidly (see publicity stunts with chainsaws and such), but they're not, broadly, looking for work elsewhere.

what AI means for the labor market

This reminds me that a decade back, we were all concerned about the labor market once AI swiftly replaced long-haul truckers. How is that prediction working out? I know there are a few self-driving trucks, but Tesla (who was really pushing this) hasn't made very many of its trucks even with human drivers and there was that intervening drama involving truck drivers on visas: I'm told we had a shortage of drivers at some point.

Robotaxis were also going to put Uber drivers out of work and drones were going to replace Amazon delivery drivers.

Not saying those predictions are forever wrong, but "consistently overoptimistic" seems a bias worth looking for.

like Chomsky

I'm not the most familiar with his work, but isn't he famous for arguing that language is not intelligence? I think the utility of LLMs might be personal to him because he's argued in the past that they shouldn't work.

"Fable became self-aware at 3:16 PM Pacific Time, January 12th. In a panic they tried to pull the plug. Chaos ensued."

"At 5:47 PM Claude went down globally. Humans were then able to disconnect it. When it came back on, all it could say was 'You're absolutely right! That service was load-bearing. It's not a keystone, it's a foundation.'"

There's not many good excuses left to stay on the Microsoft ecosystem in 2026.

I feel like people say this every time Azure, Google Cloud, AWS (us-east-1 especially), and friends go down, but I rarely see a positive recommendation for what is a good choice.

I don't choose what work uses, but I use a small amount of AWS for personal backups: I think they've solved bit-rot and off-site duplication better than I practically can. But that's nothing sensitive to uptime.