@2rafa's banner p

2rafa


				

				

				
24 followers   follows 0 users  
joined 2022 September 06 11:20:51 UTC

maybe it will all turn out fine


				

User ID: 841

2rafa


				
				
				

				
24 followers   follows 0 users   joined 2022 September 06 11:20:51 UTC

					

maybe it will all turn out fine


					

User ID: 841

"shopping with your money IRL, browsing expensive restaurants for you to take her to, farming sexual attention on social media or IRL, watching TikTok slop, shit-talking you with her girlfriends"

Raising his kids, washing his clothes, cleaning the house, buying groceries and supplies, making sure the kids get to school and to sleep and have clothes, cooking dinner, all while probably having a job of her own, while he’s out with his friends or playing golf or maybe even cheating?

It’s easy to tell sad stories about the plight of one’s sex.

I think I agree with this general argument. In time, I think we’ll realize that our brains are one of the least interesting things about us, the mechanisms in our limbs, hands, hearts, other internal organs are in many ways far more beautiful, more refined, more complex and more interesting. The brain is a simple statistical engine, and so are LLMs. Necessary, yes, special, less so. We have invented a better brain, accelerated evolution by orders of magnitude if you want to be grandiose, but the meaning we attach to that is our own.

Our ancestors were right when they dissected the brain and wondered how it was so boring, so uniform, so simple. It is.

The only ‘moat’ any of them have is if the Yud hypothesis that the first model to hit runaway RSI achieves ASI instantly and rules the future (or “the lightcone” or whatever) forever is true and if it then rewards the smart people who bought stock in (or worked at) the parent company when it IPO’d. Personally I consider that a faintly ridiculous argument, but then again the future is going to be a weird place.

If that doesn’t happen then the interchangeability of most models and the fact that cheap open source models will be increasingly suitable for most normal applications surely caps profitability at some point. Sure, AI can takeover every industry but I’m not sure government will even permit that (they may require these firms to remain largely pure play model providers) and much of the physical infrastructure they’d need to compete with established players who can just…use the AI these people make would require a lot of capital that’s getting ever more expensive for them to raise.

I think the questions now aren’t that intelligence will increase, they’re about the effect that’s going to have on our material world and lives, which involve far more unknowns.

Indonesia is also at risk because once Chinese robots get cheap enough (and involution / inter-provincial subsidy competition will handle the export financing) textiles and a lot of manufacturing is being reshored, they have 300 million mouths to feed, and the political system is a mess. Really I think these ‘second world’ / developing-ish countries will be most screwed by mass automation, they’re more reliant on robust global trade flows, have growing population with a youth bulge which is destabilizing in terms of increasing likelihood of rioting when things get worse, have limited histories of viable safety nets and so on. Indonesia produces more food than most but I’m not sure the outlook for places like them and Mexico is that positive. Really poor countries that barely developed at all will likely benefit, it’s not like Burkina Faso has a lot of software engineer jobs to automate, and while falling aid income or remittances in some places are a risk, there’s the possibility that ultra cheap Chinese robotics allow for rapidly expanded and more efficient agriculture and construction in places like this that can probably markedly improve QOL.

I think the world is going to get weird. One of the big initial questions and what I think will separate ‘winner’ nations from ‘loser’ ones is going to be - at all levels of development - whether governments are quick to understand what is happening and think through amelioration plans that prevent riots, starvation and communism while also facilitating ongoing AI-accelerated rapid productivity growth, which will be a very tough tightrope to walk. The jury is really out on that, and there’s still a chance the UK will be unexpectedly good at it not because British politicians are particularly competent, but because of unusual quirks of its constitutional system, the depths of the coming crisis for the services sector and the impetus which is already present (before the jobs have gone) for radical change here, which slowly bubbles in the general population.

The UK’s economy which as you say is built on easily automated export services will collapse faster and harder than countries with strong manufacturing sectors, more agricultural self-sufficiency and cheaper energy (like France), but many of them have their own near term issues that are worse in some ways, like even worse problems with immigration, pensions and so on.

The UK also has extreme latent state capacity, zero constitutional safeguards, an extraordinary degree of wage compression (meaning that actually the profound economic crisis and crisis of meaning that will befall the PMC in the US when they go from making $500k a year to whatever happens next won’t happen, since basically everyone in Britain except you and I makes £30-60k ie 1-2x minimum wage) and a population used to damp, shitty, small houses that are cold in the winter and hot in the summer, low quality of life, mediocre healthcare, relatively poor quality food and produce unless you’re wealthy, and limited social mobility. It’s just that the government has basically implemented socialism to spread that misery to everyone instead of just the bottom 50-60%.

Nothing ever happens in Britain until there is a crisis. Then everything can happen. But there has to be short sharp shock to get it to. Meanwhile I think places like the US and Germany will see more of a profound bleed, some winners and losers, big regional differences, and they both have political systems that make implementing radical change almost impossible or impossible without supermajorities, often in both national and regional governments due to separation of powers. In the UK, you just need 326 MPs (which you can win with ~35% of the vote) to do whatever you want, seize anything, abolish anything, build anything.

Top citizenship / residency for surviving the AI transition era is probably still Denmark or Norway due to high state competence, good demographics, small country status and quite high general trust, maybe Switzerland since even though it’s a service economy it’s quite diversified and may maintain fx safe haven status in a more dangerous world which means they can continue to finance plenty of imports. Beyond that it’s a crapshoot. Maybe New Zealand I guess, Australia is probably at least semi-fucked once the Chinese end the resource boom absolutely, but has some things in favor of it. Picking winners outside that will be hard.

I think things will get ugly in the US. On paper it is agriculturally self sufficient, well resourced in terms of metals, energy production, domestic manufacturing and infrastructure, but I think the kinds of class, regional and demographic divisions that will reveal themselves when things start changing super fast will be very destabilizing and that makes for a very difficult climate in which to build anything.

Why? These are people who will spend $15m on interior design / decoration for a mansion. They’re the people buying $100,000 light sculptures and $80,000 tables and $5m paintings, but there are also people who make a few million a year and who have a good year and have everything they want and think this sounds niche and interesting.

People will spend $250,000 for a single week on a yacht on vacation, $750k for a library is comparable.

Yes, this is a great and often underappreciated point. The smaller the unit (the business, the family, the community) the more likely genuine and viable specialization actually is.

Much of Mexico isn’t really cartel territory (it’s not important to drug or people trafficking) and so is just a generic developing country whose low salaries and close proximity to the richest nation on earth makes for plenty of economically viable industry. But yeah, life in a lot of Mexico is pretty good, at least by global standards.

How am I getting those ten extra years based on current science?

I think the core of the ‘New Zealand Plan’ beloved of Thiel, Newell and co (which I don’t necessarily endorse; I’ve written about it derisively here before) relies on the prediction that the world enters a period of profound instability, conflict and violence, maybe a ‘The Road’ style scenario in the US, or a ‘Bronze Age Collapse’. The remote reaches of the South Island of New Zealand are far from major population centers, fertile, scarcely populated, temperate and the native population that is there is almost exclusively homogenous Anglo New Zealanders (the Maori and most recent immigrants are largely concentrated on the North Island around Auckland). In this scenario they probably have weeks, months, or even years to flee and so can fly by jet or commercially. Their staff and small families live with them and are happy to come with them to escape the same problems, and they all live happily around Lake Wanaka for a few years until the problems blow over.

I think a more extreme version of what happened in Spain (?) last year, where either mobile payments and cell networks or the whole grid goes down for a few days, seems very possible. I think this is a big reason why governments are encouraging people to stockpile a week’s food and water.

Beyond this, I think that ‘full prepping’ [for the collapse / apocalypse] is more of a hobby than a reasonable precaution. Maybe if you’re a decabillionaire a hundred million for a survival compound in New Zealand is a small price for peace of mind in a very unusual tail scenario, but for everyone else I think it relies on a specific kind of ‘The Road’ style apocalypse fantasy where the world is destroyed enough to descend into lawlessness and anarchy, but enough humans survive that those who stockpiled enough guns, ammo and MREs on their Idaho ranches can live live petty lords.

I don’t think this is likely. Either civilization survives or it doesn’t, but I think in the event of a total collapse (most plausibly AI assisted or led extinction scenario or maybe nuclear MAD) either you’re not surviving or you’ll wish you didn’t.

If it was an open relationship why would he have apologized profusely to his wife and family for cheating?

This stuff often doesn’t even reach journalists unless it’s particularly salacious, like with a spy. Jensen’s previous affairs were open knowledge in the company and there were no news articles, which proves my point.

In the first Google result I see:

Nearly nine out of 10 Americans said that government corruption, as defined as elected officials putting their own or their donors’ financial interests ahead of the public’s, is a problem, according to the survey.

Three-quarters (76%) of voters said that elected officials care more about enriching themselves than improving the economy for ordinary people. Voters were more likely to say that government corruption (65%) is more concerning than corporate power (29%). Just under 10% said that neither concerns them.

This is clearly primarily about financial interests and personal enrichment, not Epstein.

Did Republicans lose the midterms because of their weak stance on no-fault divorce?

No but they did lose the midterms in part because voters were fed up of the countless examples of personal enrichment and corruption by senior administration figures, their family and friends, as per polling, which falls under the same standards for personal ethics.

In general, it is a bad idea to trust adulterers. If someone cheats on the person they purport to love most, the parent of their children, the person they swear to remain remain faithful to, why are they going to honor the petty handshakes and promises of ordinary commercial or political life?

do we need to take their jobs?

Perhaps I am. Or at least expropriate more of their property than we do entrepreneurs whose personal morals I agree with. I already advocated for taxing the unmarried and childless more, taxing users of prostitutes and surrogates (both deeply immoral) like most of those you cite more is something I completely agree with.

If you’re a famous person and you publicly cheat on your wife (to the extent that you’re pictured with your mistress many times), that’s news and literally always has been and you can’t be mad if it’s reported.

Did Jensen Huang predict crypto or transformer models? Categorically, he did not. Again, I acknowledged him as a successful businessman, which he is! But he isn’t an AI visionary. He made shovels for two consecutive colossal economic booms that he didn’t predict.

Then they can sleep around quietly without sleeping with the boss of one of your main customers who is directly involved in circumventing sanctions on high tech exports to geopolitical adversaries?

When Huang was merely sleeping with his employees quietly nobody seemed to care. Occasionally boards do, but usually only when they want to fire the boss without a payout so need cause. I am not mad that it provides a pretext for it, though, which anybody would know.

Beyond that, disincentives for elite licentiousness don’t need to be absolute to have an effect. There are surely still wealthy old producers sleeping with young actresses in the Hollywood of 2026. But they know that if they behave poorly enough, or screw over the wrong person, or exploit too many young ambitions, that the odds of a life ruining press blowup increase dramatically, and that improves conditions generally.

Not caring about the personal ethics of elites is degenerate behavior and the tech right makes itself look repulsive when it loudly does so in Jensen’s defense.

In voter polls in the midterms, one of the biggest actually reported reasons for the swing wasn’t inflation or ICE or the Iran War, it was “corruption” ie venality. In fact, in most polls it was the second or third most important issue for voters. It’s also why Orban lost, because voters could see every day how absurd it was that his childhood best friends were all billionaires, that his little ancestral village was the richest place in Hungary etc.

Private immoral behavior is unsavory in rulers but ultimately acceptable. But public degeneracy (whether it is paraded loudly or revealed by the press) is an anchor on support, if not immediately then eventually. Even Trump, history’s great survivor, has been weighed down by it now. That grotesque case of that Biden administration official arrested for stealing women’s clothes at an airport (multiple times, I think), and the wider trans issue which provokes a certain reaction in many people, no doubt contributed seriously to the 2024 result.

I really have no problem with people who cheat on their spouse losing their job. Doesn’t the US military have the same policy?

Nvidia made a product that was state of the art in videogame rendering and a handful of niche ancillary businesses like CGI movies and some simulation / modelling workflows.

It just so happened that that invention became a vital part of the development of cryptocurrency mining which became a trillion dollar industry, and then became a vital part of the most significant technological innovation since at least fire, probably ever. They therefore 500x’d in value in like 10 years. They didn’t invent AI or crypto, they were in the right place at the right time with a product everybody needed to buy. Huang is more like a Gulf royal who happened to be in charge in 1962.

Well, that’s harsh. He was still a very successful businessman. But he was not an epochal figure. In mid-2015 Nvidia was worth like $10bn.

Isn’t Sam Altman on the pro China side versus Dario Amodei?

Only in relatively liquid markets, in a bunch of less liquid ones it’s still classic electronic trading with a manual process or even just voice/email. If you’re trading obscure EM bonds Jane Street might price you electronically instantly via algo but it will be a terrible lowball for the truly desperate buyer/seller only compared to calling up a local or competent international brokerage with a local presence.

The tech right commentators are almost all hugely invested, some with leverage, into Nvidia and other AI/hyperscaler/tech stocks. Many are in the space commercially themselves and so are absolutely reliant on the boom continuing to refinance debt, raise more money, win over customers, get rich and get paid if they’re employees. Anything that shakes confidence in the AI narrative is potentially ruinously bad for them financially.

This is inseparable from their Huang boosting. I don’t think “there’s no evidence she was a spy” is interesting. If intelligence asks you as a businessperson to do something, you do it. It’s the same in Russia. At best if you refuse you lose everything and are banned from leaving or - if you’re fast and cunning - get to escape, more likely you lose everything and get disappeared for a time, at worst who knows.

So the only questions are:

  1. Did Chinese intelligence know she was having an affair with Huang while she was importing GPUs for major Chinese conglomerates after a long career in tech and private equity in Beijing and Shanghai? (Almost certainly, they were photographed together publicly, this is the most important sector globally, China is heavily surveilling execs and researchers in the space, the SEA datacenter route is the main way Chinese big tech is accessing sota GPUs, and she had extensive state-affiliated business connections).

  2. If so (and again, the answer to the previous question is yes) would they lean on a woman having an affair with the founder and head of the main company whose products, vital to the AI race, are currently being smuggled into the country? Again, the answer is obviously yes. The tech right seem to be arguing some version of “well, we don’t know if she actually found anything out”, but this isn’t even necessarily something you can confirm (she almost certainly had private access to phones, laptops etc while he was sleeping, assuming they spent at least a night together and he doesn’t have bodyguards in the room during sex…) and is extreme cope in any case.

So, simply:

(A) The CCP was probably aware of the affair and (B) This is the highest of high value targets and (C) They can and do compel cooperation from citizens with no choice - even America does this and (D) we know [Alice] Huang didn’t defect because when she was kicked out of Singapore she voluntarily returned straight to Beijing (not Indonesia or Malaysia or anywhere in SEA where Megaspeed operates but where the long arm of America can reach) where she remains, which isn’t something you do if you just gave a bunch of fake intelligence to the CCP because you felt bad.

How do you know Claude Tax is getting it right, especially in niche cases where whatever training set they use didn’t have something perfectly analogous to your scenario so it’s just trying to solve for the tax code (which by the way often invokes, as I understand it, the accounting version of ‘the spirit of the law’)?

My own tax situation is complex for a number of reasons and I pay a medium annual figure to my accountant to handle it for me. At what point do I trust Claude to do it? When I gave it what they did this year it recommended doing some things differently and approved of most of it. I certainly can’t interpret who is right or wrong.